Israeli Official Points to ‘Incitement’ by Palestinians
By JODI RUDOREN
Published: January 6, 2014 -- The New York Times
JERUSALEM — Adolf Hitler is quoted on the websites
of Palestinian Authority schools. A young girl appears on Palestinian
television, describing Jews as “barbaric monkeys, wretched pigs” and the
“murderers of Muhammad,” the Islamic prophet. Maps on the Facebook page
of the Palestinian presidential guards do not show Israel. President
Mahmoud Abbas himself embraced as “heroes” released Palestinian
prisoners who killed Israelis.
These are among dozens of examples highlighted by Israeli officials in a new presentation
documenting negative statements about Israel and Jews in official
Palestinian Authority media and textbooks. As Secretary of State John
Kerry departed here on Monday after an intense four-day push for a framework agreement
outlining prospects for a peace deal, Israeli leaders said that such
statements had not abated since negotiations began this summer and did
not bode well.
“The general phenomenon is very clear: They are poisoning Palestinian
children with deep hatred of Israel and the Jewish people,” Yuval
Steinitz, Israel’s minister of strategic affairs, said on Monday as he
showed the presentation to international reporters. “At the end of the
day, let’s assume we’ll be able to resolve all the technical issues,
which are extremely complicated. Are we going to get genuine peace, or
just a piece of paper?”
Video by a Jordanian production company "Bird of Paradise."
The 2010 song, "When We Die as Martyrs," is cited as influential among Palestinian children in Israel's report.
The presentation, which Mr. Steinitz delivered at an Israeli cabinet meeting on Sunday, is part of an intensifying campaign
in which he, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and others have
emphasized what they call “incitement” as a prime obstacle to peace. It
underpins their increasing demand for Palestinian recognition
of Israel as a Jewish state, which they argue is the only way they will
be assured that an agreement will end the long-running conflict.
Palestinian leaders dismiss the renewed focus on incitement as a ruse to
distract from disagreements over issues including borders, the future
of Jerusalem and the rights of refugees. They say that Israel has
refused to reconvene a committee, which included Americans, that was
established in 1998 to deal with incitement but disbanded after two
years and about 20 meetings.
“If there is any incitement against Israel, this is a forum where they
can provide it officially, and we can do the same,” said Majdi Khaldi, a
diplomatic adviser to Mr. Abbas. “Why do we have to continue just
complaints from one to the other? It’s better for all to go to the
trilateral committee, and that will solve the whole issue.”
Asked about reviving the committee, Mr. Steinitz said Monday that it had
been “completely useless” and would not help because the problems were
coming from Palestinian government sources, not rogue individuals.
Mr. Khaldi says the problems go both ways. He pointed out that Israel’s
foreign minister, Avigdor Lieberman, has repeatedly accused Mr. Abbas of
“diplomatic terrorism,” and said he also saw Israel’s continued
construction in West Bank settlements and military raids on Palestinian
cities as forms of incitement.
Xavier Abu Eid, a spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization,
noted that weather maps in Israeli newspapers do not demarcate
Palestinian territory, just as maps cited in Mr. Steinitz’s report do
not show the land divided.
Incitement is an issue as old as the conflict itself. An unusually comprehensive recent study
of Israeli and Palestinian Authority textbooks found that each
presented the other side as the enemy, but that the Palestinian books
contained more negative characterizations. David Pollock, a fellow at
the Washington Institute for Near East Policy who in September published
a 172-page study of the issue,
said that while incitement had decreased markedly since the second
intifada, or Palestinian uprising, a decade ago, it persists.
“There are ups and downs, there are exceptions,” Mr. Pollock said in an
interview, “but unfortunately I think it is true that the official
Palestinian media continue to incite against Israel and to claim that
all of Palestine belongs to the Palestinians. There’s almost no positive
discussion of peace, two peoples, any of that sort of favorable or even
just moderate messages about Israel.”
On the Israeli side, Mr. Pollock said, “what you have are unofficial,
extremist fringe individuals” whose statements are “disowned and
discouraged, for the most part,” by government leaders.
Mr. Steinitz’s ministry has four people working full time tracking
incitement, and since 2009 it has issued quarterly reports trying to
quantify it. Mr. Steinitz said that numbers for the fall of 2013 were
not yet available, but that “amazingly, surprisingly, since the
resumption of the negotiations we see even more incidents.”
On the Nov. 2 anniversary of the Balfour Declaration of 1917, in which Britain endorsed the idea of a Jewish state in Palestine, the website of Mr. Abbas’s presidential guards posted bloodied pictures of Arthur Balfour,
the British foreign secretary for whom the declaration is named, and
Israeli prime ministers under the banner, “A promise from one who did
not own it to one who did not deserve it,” according to the
presentation.
The same site, on the Nov. 29 anniversary
of the 1947 United Nations vote to partition Palestine, had a headline,
“Palestine Is Not to Be Divided,” with a map that did not show Israel.
The presentation also included a picture of a Nazi flag hung in the West Bank village of Beit Ummar in October.
And there was a November video on a website of Mr. Abbas’s Fatah faction
in which masked members of its military wing threatened to kidnap
Israeli soldiers and showed off weapons, singing, “With these rockets we
will liberate Jerusalem, with these rockets we will crush the Zionist
enemy.”
Mr. Steinitz said that Mr. Netanyahu had shown Mr. Kerry some of these
examples during a recent meeting in Rome. The prime minister also
complained about incitement in an August letter to Mr. Kerry, and has
frequently raised the issue in his public statements since the
negotiations began.
“This Palestinian government incitement is rampant,” Mr. Netanyahu said at a joint appearance with Mr. Kerry when he arrived here on Thursday. “Instead of preparing Palestinians for peace, Palestinian leaders are teaching them to hate Israel.”
A version of this article appears in print on January 7, 2014, on page A4 of the New York edition with the headline: Israeli Official Points to ‘Incitements’ by Palestinians.
Labels: Conflict, Hypocrisy, Israel, Negotiations, Palestinian Authority, Peace, Propaganda, United States
posted by Pieface @ Tuesday, January 07, 2014
<< Home