Lawless Sinai Shows Risks Rising in Fractured Egypt
Narciso Contreras for The New York Times
By ROBERT F. WORTH
Published: August 10, 2013
SHEIKH ZWAYD, Egypt — Every night at dusk, the streets of this desert
town near the Israeli border empty out, and the chatter and thump of
gunfire and explosives begin. Morning reveals the results: another dead
soldier, another police checkpoint riddled with bullets, another
kidnapping. In mid-July, the body of a local Christian shop owner was
found near the town cemetery, his head severed, his torso in chains.
The northern Sinai Peninsula, long a relatively lawless zone, has become
a dark harbinger of what could follow elsewhere in Egypt if the interim
government cannot peacefully resolve its standoff with the Islamist
protesters camped out in Cairo.
In the five weeks since Egypt’s military ousted the Islamist president,
Mohamed Morsi, the endemic violence here has spiraled into something
like an insurgency, with mysterious gunmen attacking military and police
facilities every night.
Last week, the violence threatened to draw in Israel. On Thursday,
Israel briefly closed an airport at the Red Sea resort of Eilat after
Egyptian officials warned about the possibility of militants firing
rockets from Sinai. The next day,
up to five suspected militants were killed and a rocket launcher was
destroyed in an airstrike in Sinai, the state news media reported, and
there were unconfirmed reports that Israel had carried out the strike.
The Sinai attacks have taken about 62 lives, officials say, not counting
the 60 suspects the Egyptian authorities claim to have killed. There
has also been a troubling rise in attacks on Christians, who are fleeing
the area in large numbers.
Although the world’s attention has been focused on Cairo, where about
140 Islamist Muslim Brotherhood supporters have been killed in clashes
with the police since Mr. Morsi’s ouster, the chaos in Sinai in some
ways represents a more troubling prospect. Unlike the Brotherhood, which
has a longstanding commitment to nonviolence, the jihadists here are
out for blood, and they appear to have been energized by the military’s
reassertion of power. Some Egyptians fear a renewal of the kind of
terrorism they suffered during the 1990s, especially if the military
resorts to an even broader and more forceful crackdown.
The northern Sinai may be both a symptom and a cause of Egypt’s
festering crisis: one of the military’s reasons for ousting Mr. Morsi
was the belief that he was too soft on the jihadists here and saw them
as potential allies. Yet the military, for all its warlike talk, seems
unable to thwart the mysterious bands of gunmen who own the night here.
“We are living in a state of constant terror, but we see nothing from
the police or the army,” said Mitri Shawqi Mitri, a 53-year-old
Christian shopkeeper whose son, Mina, was kidnapped by gunmen early this
month. “Everything has stopped for us, there is no work, all the
churches have closed, the priests have fled.”
Like many Christians living in Sinai, Mr. Mitri plans to leave, and a
wall of his modest house in the town of El Arish has the words “For
Sale” scrawled on it in Arabic. At least one Christian priest here has
been killed in the past month, and several Christians have been
kidnapped, including two women and Magdy Lamy, the shopkeeper who was
beheaded. Many others have received death threats from militant
Islamists warning them to leave Sinai, Mr. Mitri and other local
Christians said.
As Mr. Mitri sat talking to a reporter in his home, he received a text
message from the kidnappers, who were demanding a ransom of 150,000
Egyptian pounds, about $21,500. “They want to know if I have the money
in the house with me,” he said, his face creased with anger and fear.
The military announced last week on its Facebook page that its
counterterrorism operation over the past month in Sinai had led to 103
arrests, and the destruction of 102 tunnels, 40 underground fuel storage
tanks and 4 houses used by extremists. The reference to tunnels,
presumably those used to smuggle weapons and goods into Gaza, tallies
with the military’s routine suggestions that Hamas, the Palestinian
militant group that controls Gaza, is involved in the violence. However,
there is no evidence to suggest that is true.
Most residents here say the authorities appear to be on the defensive,
with soldiers and the police hunkered down at their posts and suffering
daily casualties.
Although the attackers mainly hit the police and the military, a dozen
civilians have been killed in the cross-fire and many others have been
wounded, according to local hospital officials. Hanny Aish, a worker at a
cement factory, was on a bus in the wee hours of July 15 when a
rocket-propelled grenade crashed through the window, killing 3 of the 20
people on board and wounding the rest.
“I was sitting behind the driver, and all of a sudden I had flesh and
blood all over me,” Mr. Aish, who suffered glass cuts across his body
and shattered eardrums, said during an interview at his home.
The attackers’ target appears to have been an armored vehicle that
passed by just afterward. But as in the rest of Egypt, even the most
basic perceptions of the conflict reflect a bitter division between
supporters and opponents of Mr. Morsi. The first group tends to blame
the military for all the recent attacks here, saying it is staging fake
jihadist attacks to build a pretext for a future crackdown.
Sameh Muhammad, a conservative Muslim whose brother Salem was killed in
the same bus attack in which Mr. Aish was wounded, said he believed an
Egyptian military jet had fired a missile at the bus — despite the
testimony of witnesses like Mr. Aish and photographs that appear to show
that the bus was struck from the side.
“We heard that a witness saw the jet firing a rocket at the bus,” said
Mr. Muhammad, a religious teacher dressed in a white skullcap and gown,
with the long, scraggly beard of a hard-line Salafist Muslim. “They
always say that Islamists have done this kind of crime,” he said, as a
pretext “to crack down on the whole movement.”
Jihadism has long been a problem in Sinai, which was under Israeli
occupation from 1967 to 1982. The area’s independent Bedouin tribes have
resisted full integration into the state, and smuggling and drug
trafficking to neighboring Israel and Gaza have been rampant here for
decades.
But the Egyptian state has contributed to the problem, local leaders
say. “They treated us all as traffickers and criminals, and this
marginalization made a fertile ground for terrorism,” said Sheik
Abdelhadi Etaik Sawarka, a leader of one of the area’s main tribes.
After the 2011 revolution in Egypt, the security services withdrew from
Sinai, leaving a vacuum where armed Islamists thrived, and some foreign
fighters filtered into the area. The militants also gained access to
more sophisticated weapons from Libya after the civil war in that
country, analysts say.
There are persistent rumors that the fighters have acquired
surface-to-air missiles that could threaten aircraft in Egypt and
Israel, though these have not been confirmed.
The identities of the attackers in Sinai remain mysterious: no one has
claimed responsibility, and the Egyptian authorities have said little
about them, helping to fuel conspiracy theories. But “it appears that
Islamist militants are taking advantage of a fluid situation,” said
Michael Wahid Hanna, an expert on Egyptian politics and the military at
the Century Foundation.
The biggest concern for the United States and Israel, Mr. Hanna added,
is “the possibility that Egypt has lost control over what’s going on in
the Sinai.”
Some Islamists and Bedouins here claim that Mr. Morsi’s administration
was a welcome relief from the heavy-handed approach of Hosni Mubarak and
his predecessors. But the change was mostly a matter of tone. Mr. Morsi
ordered a crackdown on the jihadists, especially after 16 soldiers were
killed by gunmen at a Sinai military base last August, though the
subsequent military campaign was short and yielded few results.
All the Islamic groups with an official presence here deny
responsibility for the recent violence. But some of the more
conservative Islamists also talk with a certain confidence about their
situation, as if they held a trump card.
“If the military pushes the Brotherhood down here, it will have to push
all the Islamic groups down, because they are all supporting the
Brotherhood,” said Sheik Asaad el-Bayk, a Shariah court judge and a
leader in a new hard-line Islamic movement called People of the Sunna
and the Community. “They cannot do that, because it would mean major
violence.”
Labels: Conflict, Egypt, Hamas, Islamism, Muslim Brotherhood, Sinai, Terrorism
<< Home