Sunday, May 18, 2025

Victims of Communism -- Complicit with Nazism

"Over the years, we have submitted documentation detailing the atrocities committed by several individuals on the [memorial] list -- including in 2021, when we provided comprehensive evidence of the war crimes committed by Janis Niedra against Latvia's Jewish population."
"It is deeply disturbing that, despite our repeated warnings and the clear, documented evidence, the name of a Nazi involved in the murder of Jews during the Holocaust was ultimately engraved on the Memorial."
"This is simply unacceptable."
Jaime Kirzner-Roberts, senior director, Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center 
https://smartcdn.gprod.postmedia.digital/ottawacitizen/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/communism-victims-memorial_jo02_295576911.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&w=564&h=423&type=webp&sig=byQ17pSYyYBA7CKCpxCUZA
 
The seemingly endless saga of the The Victims of Communism Memorial's Wall of Remembrance goes on and on, with no end in sight, and no enlightenment by the Department of Canadian Heritage. More latterly revealed is that despite having been warned in 2021 that a Nazi collaborator who actively took part in the execution of Jews during the Holocaust, his name nonetheless was engraved to be placed among hundreds of others purporting to be victims of Communism, on a monument that sought to sanctify them as heroes for opposing Communism.
 
The nameplate that was meant to commemorate Janis Niedra had been installed on the memorial in 2023, according to government records obtained under the Access to Information Act, then later removed. By the time the memorial was formally opened in late 2024, no names were installed on the memorial. The inexplicable reason that Canadian Heritage permitted the commemorative nameplate for Niedra -- despite warnings from the Friends of Sion Wiesenthal Center for Holocaust Studies -- to be originally installed has never been explained. 

The Department had been provided with research data indicating that Niedra had led a group of some 40 men on a mission to assist the Nazis in rounding up and executing about 350 Latvian Jews; mostly women, children and seniors. Niedra died in 1969, but it was known that he served the Nazis in various positions in Latvia. He arrived in Canada following war's end. Ricochet Media, an investigative online news outlet, had reported the existence of the nameplate.
 
Niedra's name had been removed before the public inauguration of the memorial after having been flagged in 2023 when a Canadian Heritage employer raised concerns regarding the man's Nazi connections. The main concern in the department was that the public, or news media, might recognize the name engraved on the memorial. That nameplate, as well as others for the memorial "are being stored at a National Capital commission facility" Canadian Heritage spokesperson Caroline Czajkowski confirmed. 
 
https://smartcdn.gprod.postmedia.digital/ottawacitizen/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/communism-victims-memorial_jo01_295576913.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&w=564&type=webp&sig=gR4S_uBaXqmVMZFrUZa65A
The memorial sits on the west side of the Garden of the Provinces and Territories in downtown Ottawa. Photo by JULIE OLIVER /POSTMEDIA
 
Canadian Heritage had been repeatedly warned that numerous individuals slated to be honoured on the memorial did not represent victims; they were instead Nazi collaborators responsible for having played significant rules in the Holocaust and in perpetrating other crimes against humanity. Concerns were raised by Jewish organizations and historians that names of eastern Europeans who had collaborated with the Nazis during the Holocaust had been nominated in a deliberate move to whitewash their past. 

Roman Shukheyvych, a Ukrainian nationalist who collaborated with the Nazis and who was linked to the massacres of Jews and Poles, was among those being commemorated. Only after, in 2021, the Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center repeatedly raised the matter with the department, had Shukheyvych's name finally been removed. Ludwik Klimkowski, chairman of Tribute to Liberty, posted on social media platform X his sentiments regarding concerns that the monument was honouring Nazi collaborators: "Let's stop the nonsense of the Nazi commemoration perpetrated by Canadian Marxists and the agents of the Kremlin's regime", he wrote.
 
"It's important to note that many anti-Communist and anti-Soviet advocates and fighters were also active Nazi collaborators, who committed documented massacres", Global Affairs Canada officials warned their counterparts at Canadian Heritage in 2021, as federal officials in other departments also continued to warn Canadian Heritage that including Nazi collaborators on the memorial would be the cause of international embarrassment for Canada. 

A report prepared for Canadian Heritage in 2024 had recommended that over half of the 550 names proposed for inclusion on the memorial should be removed because of potential links to Nazi Germany's 'Final Solution'. There were originally to be 553 entries on the memorial's Wall of Remembrance. Some 50 to 60 names or organizations had already been determined by the department itself, to have likely been directly linked to the Nazis, according to the documents. 
"In 2021, we discovered that one particular Nazi leader was being honoured by the Memorial and it took us more than a year of very active advocacy efforts before his name was finally removed."
"We told officials repeatedly that we believed there could be a great number of Nazis being commemorated but sadly this problem did not appear to be a priority for the department."
"[The recent report commissioned by the department confirmed her organization’s worst fears], It finds that more half of the individuals commemorated in the memorial may have been Nazis or Nazi collaborators."
"It is totally unacceptable for Nazis and collaborators to be honoured by a Canadian public memorial, especially one meant to recognize victims of state violence and tyranny."
Jaime Kirzner-Roberts
https://smartcdn.gprod.postmedia.digital/ottawacitizen/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/communism-victims-memorial_jo04_295576917.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&w=564&type=webp&sig=YfWg8hKvestIQbyeBJKdKg
The memorial opened in late 2024. Photo by JULIE OLIVER /POSTMEDIA

 

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, October 08, 2024

Memorializing Victims of Communism Who Were Nazi Collaborators

"A Wall of Remembrance that honours all the victims of Communism named in this document will attract controversy and criticism. Several of the named victims were fascists and Nazi collaborators or belonged to groups that might be described as such."
"We do not have details about the wartime activities of most of the named victims who were members of the OUN-UPA."
"[…] It would be tricky to know where to draw the line. The department [Canadian Heritage] may have to decide whether it should honour any members of the OUN-UPA at all."
"[There was insufficient information about roughly half the names listed for commemoration, although these included several names that belonged to] individuals who appear not to have been directly impacted by Communism, including because they were born in Canada."
Historian Michael Petrou
 
"[There have been criticisms and concerns for years] about the monument being a ‘countermeasure’ to the Holocaust Monument, about the need to ‘elevate’ the suffering of the victims of Communism to the level of the Holocaust. Scholars refer to this as 'Holocaust envy'."
"I also heard about the planned individual commemoration of some very unsavoury characters, some of them linked to mass murder of Jews during the Holocaust."
University of Ottawa historian Jan Grabowski  
https://www.readthemaple.com/content/images/size/w2000/2024/04/Memorial_to_the_Victims_of_Communism_-_Canada-_a_Land_of_Refuge_complete_but_closed_2812.jpeg
Photo credit: Ahunt via Wikimedia Commons. Licensed under Public Domain.
Over half of the 550 names on the Memorial to the Victims of Communism should be removed on the basis of potential links to the Nazis, it has been revealed. There are questions relating to affiliations with fascist groups, according to government records held by the Department of Canadian Heritage. In the original plans for the memorial, 553 entries were planned for the Ottawa memorial's Wall of Remembrance.

After investigation, the Department of Canadian Heritage felt confident that 40 to 60 of the names or organizations likely had been linked directly to the Nazis. A recommendation of over 330 names to be excluded was included in a 2023 report for Canadian Heritage. Because of the lack of full information regarding the individuals or organizations in question, and to be on the safe side, the exclusions were recommended, rather than risk giving then an all-clear, then discovering they were linked to fascist organizations or the Nazis of WWII.

The purpose of the memorial was to honour those who suffered under Communism. But if that also meant they had links to fascism and Nazism, as pointed out by historians, they would hardly qualify under the possibility that those who were complicit in murdering Jews be honoured by default. Concerns exist, over names of eastern Europeans who had collaborated during the Holocaust with the Nazi regime have been nominated in an effort to whitewash an inglorious past.

Because of the ongoing uncertainty and controversy, Canadian Heritage has not yet set a new date for the unveiling, after the original date was cancelled due to new incriminating evidence and recommendations for caution to be exercised.  "The review of the commemorative elements is ongoing" was the response when a Heritage representative was asked whether the more then 330 entries on the Wall of Remembrance would be removed.

https://i.cbc.ca/1.4007614.1488500343!/fileImage/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/original_1180/team-raff.jpg
The winning design for the Memorial to the Victims of Communism was created by Toronto architect and artist Paul Raff. Its scale was drastically reduced from the original, which was supposed to be located near the Supreme Court of Canada before being moved across Wellington Street amid controversy. (Supplied) CBC

Labels: , , , ,

Follow @rheytah Tweet