The Subjective Politicisation of Canadian Universities
"It's
been 21 years since I attended the first 'Israeli Apartheid Week' at
the University of Toronto. Since then, I have been on the front lines
witnessing countless demonstrations, anti-Israel speakers and even the
now infamous 'boycott, divestment and sanctions' campaigns promulgating
hate against the Jewish state and Jewish students. The situation has
only gotten worse for our children."
"Who
would have thought that the Palestinian flag would make an acceptable
appearance at some graduation ceremonies this past spring?"
"The
consequences of these sobering statistics are transforming how Jewish
students live and learn as they and their parents worry for their
safety, given the report's finding that 22 percent have experienced some
sort of physical violence."
Avi Abraham Benlolo, CEO, The Abraham Global Peace Initiative
Arab Israelis make up:
22% of Israel's population David Jacobs, X
Jewish-Canadian
students are preparing to return to their university studies for the
2026 school year. The past three years, since October 7, 2023, academic
attendance has taught Jewish students, all the way from elementary
school, up to high school and post-secondary institutions that they are
very special indeed. They are the only minority group in Canada that has
been exposed to raw hate, from their teachers, through an altered
curriculum, and from their non-Jewish classmates. School trustees rather
than focus on academic performance and excellence in the role of
schools in teaching a new Canadian generation have been involved in
identity politics. School administrations wanly reject antisemitism, but
not without pairing it with 'Islamophobia'.
What
no one seems to want to mention is that these waves of torrid hate
toward Jews long kept under wraps within the civilized society Canada
once prided itself on being, has been unleashed by Palestinian students
with support from the larger Canadian Muslim population involved in the
slander of Israel and the none-too-subtle harassment of Canada's Jewish
population, with an especial focus on the most vulnerable; the children
of Canada's Jewish community. A community dwarfed in size by the
presence of a much larger Muslim population which over the last decade
has grown enormously through immigration, refugee intake and acceptance
of illegal migrants.
For
three years and counting, Jewish students and Jewish faculty members of
universities across Canada have had to cope with campus encampments
dedicated to validating, supporting and mounting campaigns addressed to
maligning, belittling, isolating the presence of Jews on campus as dread
and unforgivable 'Zionists' who support the right of Jews to favour and
defend the Jewish homeland of Israel, the Jewish state reborn on its
ancient ancestral geographic footprint in the Middle East.
A sign is seen urging the university's pension
plan to divest from companies that do business with Israel, at the
encampment set up at the University of Toronto in May 2024.Photo by Jesse Kline/National Post
A professor wrote that we need to kill all Zionists, that she had worked with them and saw how evil they were.
I was told by a professor, in class, in the middle of the lecture, that Jews belong in Poland and need to go back.
I
faced extreme pressure from other student organizations to release a
statement against Zionism in my position as president of the (redacted)
student union, and had my name placed on a list circulating on and off
campus as a 'known Zionist'.
Professor
assigned us to listen to a podcast that discussed how Zionism was
similar to Nazism, which was unrelated to the course.
I
was harassed online ... She went as far as spamming my art page for
five days straight, sending me radical reels, calling my elderly family
'killers'.
Residents
at my on-campus residence started rumours about me that I am a child
killer, white supremacist, racist, and Zionist, all because these people
found out that I was Jewish.
Jews were described as greedy for money in a lecture.
In
a course that had nothing to do with Israel, my professor spent three
weeks talking about Gaza and the creation of the State of Israel. He
never mentioned the Holocaust as a precursor to its founding, repeatedly
calling the state a 'Zionist political project'.
When
discussing characters in a book, my professor described one character
by saying that 'based on his last name, he is clearly Jewish and
probably has a hooked nose'.
Working in my labs, I have had people refuse to work with me due to my Jewish identity and purposely try to mess up my data.
Several
faculty members in my program minimized the Holocaust or used it to
condemn the Israeli response immediately after October 7.
Shortly
after October 7, I told my PhD supervisor that I did not feel safe on
campus and she replied: 'Well, you should see the other side'.
A
member of my anti-racism research lab at the university minimized the
impact of the Holocaust while the other lab members remained silent. For
example, she said: 'The Holocaust was not the first time gas chambers
were used. They were first used against Indigenous peoples in Canada.'
When I raised this with my research supervisor, now tenured, her
reaction was to protect the student responsible. For example, she said:
'What happens in the lab stays in the lab'.
National Post Staff
"Over the past few weeks, CAUT has become aware of a number of disturbing
cases in which university administrations have limited or suppressed
debate on controversial issues. Whether it is banning posters or noisy
demonstrations, we believe such heavy-handed actions constitute a clear
threat to the purpose of post-secondary education." "Not surprisingly, the failures involve bitterly contentious issues. One
is Middle East politics. Last month Carleton University and the
University of Ottawa banned a student organization poster for Israeli
Apartheid Week because the universities felt it too provocative. The
poster, by noted political cartoonist Carlos Latuff, shows a stylized
Israeli warplane firing a missile at a child holding a teddy bear and
standing on ground emblazoned with the word “Gaza.” York University has
gone even farther, invoking a noise policy to justify handing club
suspensions and fines to student organizations that held
counter-protests for and against Israeli government policies." "In invoking the need to be “respectful” and “civil” and to avoid
“provocation,” too many universities are suppressing free speech and
freedom of expression. Some universities are even stretching to invoke
human rights’ codes to justify suppression when these codes typically
address the right to be free from discrimination in employment and in
access to services and accommodations and are not meant to silence
campus discussion and debate." "Our institutions must remember the integrity of their central mission,
which is so aptly described in the University of Toronto’s statement of
institutional purpose: that “within the unique university context, the
most crucial of all human rights are the rights of freedom of speech,
academic freedom and freedom of research,” and affirms that “these
rights are meaningless unless they entail the right to raise deeply
disturbing questions and provocative challenges to the cherished beliefs
of society at large and of the university itself.”" "The statement concludes: “It is this human right to radical, critical
teaching and research with which the University has a duty above all to
be concerned; for there is no one else, no other institution and no
other office, in our modern liberal democracy, which is the custodian of
this most precious and vulnerable right of the liberated human spirit.” "
"I feel betrayed. As a dues-paying member and local executive for 18 years, to have them turn on me like this. I feel unheard, unwelcome and totally ignored."
"I have many allies who are not Jewish asking the same questions -- why is our union spending money and time on this and not getting the approval from the membership?"
OPSEU member Daz Salama
"After everything Jewish members have already been through, it's like getting kicked when you're already down."
"Here I am, paying union dues for people to effectively call for my death at these activities."
"There must be business that's not getting done or being pushed back because of this laser-focus on international conflict. That's not fair to [union membership]."
"How are they being represented fairly when focus and resources are being taken away? How is this good for the union?"
Lindsay Gilbert, Jewish OPSEU member
"[Our membership is] united [in concern over the] spiral of death and destruction [in the region]."
"As a social justice union, we believe that unions and the broader labour movement must fight for labour rights and human rights -- not just at home, but everywhere."
"Our union has a long and proud record of actively contributing to the struggle against South African apartheid through the boycott of South African goods."
Ontario Public Service Employees Union
"Unions are exceeding their statutory mandate in advancing these agendas."
"The purpose of being in a union is not to have your union advance political issues on your behalf. The purpose of being in a union ... is to negotiate better working conditions."
"That's the unfair situation that Jewish or pro-Israel members of unions find themselves in."
Employment lawyer Daniel Lublin
"Equating the innocent hostages held by Hamas, a listed terror organization with suspected and convicted terrorists being detained by Israel is morally reprehensible."
"It is unbecoming of a Canadian union to interject itself into an international conflict and to endorse inflammatory positions that conflict with Canada's anti-racism strategy."
Richard Robertson, B'nai Brith Canada
NationalPost.com
Union members are unable under contract rules to opt out of paying monthly union dues. Union members feeling that their best interests are not being carried out by their union have little recourse other than to complain to union heads, who in fact have little interest in hearing from their members as they and they alone produce the rules and directives the union will follow. The Ontario Public Service Employees Union executive last month adopted a motion in support of the BDS (boycott, divestment and sanctions) campaign, designed to isolate Israel while supporting Palestinians.
An "immediate end to Israel's blockade, bombing and invasion of Gaza, and the mass detentions and killings of Palestinian civilians in the West Bank" forms part of the OPSEU resolution. Alongside support for an international ban on arms agreements with Israel, as well as for OPSEU locals and other unions to "advocate, mobilize and build" a number of "public campaigns" in support of Palestinians while exhibiting hostility to Israel.
Earlier in the year, OPSEU union flags were flown at an anti-Israel rally taking place in Toronto. Participants supporting shipping attacks by the Yemeni terrorist organization Houthis chanted "Yemen, Yemen make us proud, turn another ship around". Approval was evident among those present of the Yemeni Houthi slogans including "Death to Israel", and "Curse the Jews". The union's Jewish members were understandably incredulous and affronted.
Public Service Unions at the federal, provincial and academic levels -- since the October 7 terrorist attack by Hamas in southern Israel that slaughtered 1,200 Israelis and brought 240 as hostages to Gaza -- have shockingly supported Hamas, a proscribed terrorist group in Canada, while charging Israel with genocide against Palestinians. Effectively picking up the slanderous accusations levelled by the Palestinian propaganda machine to portray the charges as reality; exonerating Palestinian savagery against Israeli civilians as a necessary step in the fight for freedom from 'oppression'
It is not and never has been Israel that has attacked its neighbours; the reverse has always been the case. The Israeli military was forced to respond historically to episodic declarations of war by the Middle East's majority Islamic states, just as the Israel Defense Forces are deployed for self-protective purposes against the never-ending onslaught of violent and most often deadly attacks by Palestinians against the Israeli civilian population. October 7 represented the recent and most heinous of those deadly attacks.
Since the occurrence of the October 7 mass terror attack of murder, sexual assault, mutilation and killing of entire families in small border farming villages, union leaders have become more preoccupied with anti-Israel causes. Jewish members of the federal Public Service Alliance of Canada took their union to Canada's human rights tribunal with the accusation of the leadership having fostered a "culture of discrimination and harassment".
As justification for OPSEU's support of the BDS movement, their statement placed Israel in the same league as the once racist apartheid South African government. Brushing away as irrelevant the reality that over twenty percent of the Israeli population is Arab Palestinian with full citizenship and the right to elect their own representatives in the Israeli parliament.
Protesters attend a rally in Toronto on Sunday Jan. 14, 2024. Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS/Arlyn McAdorey
"BDS campaigns, which should be understood as 'ban Jews' campaigns, do nothing to promote peace, and harm efforts to bring Israelis and Palestinians closer together."
"The movement unfairly demonizes Israel as the sole perpetrator of the conflict, creating a one-sided narrative that removes all responsibility from the other parties, including Hamas -- reflecting the soft racism of low expectations."
Shimon Koffler Fogel, president, CEO, Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs
Bringing Some Healing to the World Through Sport : Israel
"As Indigenous peoples, we have both seen our traditional lands colonized, our people ethnically cleansed and massacred by colonial settlers." "We are asking you to respect our nonviolent picket line by withdrawing from the 2018 World Lacrosse Championships, denying Israel the opportunity to use the national sport of the Iroquois to cover up its escalating, violent ethnic cleansing of Palestinians throughout our ancestral lands." Palestinian Campaign for Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI)
"What's going on in Israel and what's happened to the Palestinians is wrong. A lot of people are relating it to what's happened to Native American people in Canada and the U.S., and it is similar." "Morally, I want to [show] support and I'm going to support them in the best way I can. But taking myself away from the game that's given me so much, and something that's very positive to our people, I don't think is the right decision for us as Haudenosaunee people." Lyle Thompson, elite Iroquois lacrosse player, Iroquois Nationals
"Our position is that we're coming to play a medicine game. Were hoping to bring some healing to the world." "There are so many things that plague indigenous communities. It's good to have people who are competing at the world level, who can be these beacons of hope and be positive out there and walk the walk." Ansley Jemison, executive director, Iroquois Nationals
Lyle Thompson (second from left) poses with
his brothers Jerome (left), Miles (second from right) and Jeremy before a
National Lacrosse League game between the Georgia Swarm and the
Saskatchewan Rush.Handout /
Cornwall Standard-Freeholder via Postmedia Network
Israel is hosting lacrosse's most important tournament this week in Netanya, Israel, the world field lacrosse championship, held every four years. A leading member of the Iroquois Nationals, the transnational Iroquois Confederacy's international competition representative and star player, Lyle Thompson, was the recipient of a July 4 open letter from the Palestinian Campaign for Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel, whose purpose was to persuade him and the team to forego competition because it was taking place in Israel this year.
Netanya Stadium (courtesy GoNetanya.com)
The Nationals is the third ranking team in the world behind Canada and the United States. And they have decided there is no way they can refrain from the opportunity to compete, irrespective of where the international competition is being played. After he received PACBI's letter, Thompson revealed that he is unfamiliar with the controversial relations between Israel and the Palestinians. He did, however, he said, briefly discuss the historical conflict with friends and did some cursory reading leading him to empathize with the Palestinians.
Whether he read actual unbiased historical accounts of the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians with an open mind rather than allowing himself to be persuaded by pervasive slanderous propaganda that has been so successfully promulgated by industrious Palestinian public relations in support of the 'cause' of the Palestinians is doubtful. Slander is just so much more approachable and easy to digest than the laborious details of actual events and a parsing of violence inflicted by those claiming to be non-violent while clasping a pathology of martyrdom.
The
Iroquois Nationals arrived in Israel hours before they're scheduled to
take on the United States at the 2018 Men's World Lacrosse Championship. (Submitted by Federation International Lacrosse)
'Normalization' with Israel is anathema to the Palestinians. For their claims are that they represent the original inhabitants of the land that heritage and history attribute through archaeology and ancient accounts of Israel written by scholars and historians of the day to a historical Jewish presence. The Palestinians are as much indigenous to the area they claim Israel has taken from them as British colonials are today as Canadian citizens.The land on which Israel sits, along with the West Bank are in fact, ancestral Jewish lands.
But the reality is that newly re-founded Israel has given status of recognition, equality and citizenship to those Palestinians who remained when Israel declared its sovereign status while those who fled as invading Arab armies sought to destroy the fledgling state now have possession of a portion of the territory that the United Nations offered through partition, and which they adamantly refused. And in Canada the indigenous population is now inclusive of the descendants of the original colonists along with the First Nations that met them.
Scott Neiss (far right), Executive Director for the Israel Lacrosse
Association and Miriam Feirberg-Ikar (center-holding Israel Lacrosse
jersey), Mayor of Netanya, hold a press conference on Wednesday, 23 May
2017, to announce Israel’s hosting of the 2018 FIL Men’s Lacrosse World
Championship.
"I honestly think they only apologized because of all the attention they got, so it's not genuine." "I will never go there." Stav Daron, Israeli tourist in Canada
Facebook/Stav Daron Stav Daron, who was rejected entry to a Canadian trade school for being from Israel.
"Due to the conflict and illegal settlement activity in the region, we are not accepting applications from Israel." "Decisions being made halfway around the world [influenced us in suspending the welcome of Israeli nationals despite some having attended the school in the past]." "We are still inclusive and cannot support that which is not inclusive." Patricia Rokosh, manager, Island School of Building Arts, Gulf Islands, British Columbia
Post-intervention: "After significant thought and listening to all interested parties, ISBA [Island School of Building Arts], has decided to rescind any restriction placed on accepting students from Israel and apologize for any inconvenience." "[This policy was a] mistake in the interpretation of the United Nations declaration." Patricia Rokosh manager, ISBA, Gabriola Island, B.C.
Under the province of British Columbia Human Rights Code businesses may not legally discriminate based on "place of origin". Israeli Stav Daron, hearing from other Israelis about their having registered as students in this unique school specializing in timber joinery, thought it would be a good idea to sign up for a four-week course while visiting Canada on a honeymoon trip. He contacted the school from Israel to register ahead for the $2,500 course.
The school's website describes itself as an open, friendly environment welcoming to international students. English proficiency was not requirement, since "Joinery is a visual medium with language playing a minor role ... don't worry". Timber joinery represents a form of wood construction where no nails are required, a specialization dating back centuries. The Israeli had read a textbook published by the school to prepare himself ahead of time and was eager for the experience.
That a Canadian trade school would reach the conclusion based on some unspecified UN declaration that it would be incumbent upon it as an 'inclusive' environment to ensure they would not be contaminated by the presence of a representative of an 'occupying power' resonates more with a Muslim-majority regime, than any enterprise established in Canada. In refusing entry to an Israeli it is even more than remotely possible that they violated Canadian law.
After Mr. Daron received the rejection to his application based solely on the fact that he was an Israeli, attempting to register with the school directly from Israel before embarking on his Canadian honeymoon trip, he sent an email back to the school administrator pointing out the hypocrisy of the ban targeting Israelis. Ms. Rokosh responded with the information that although some Israelis had been accepted in the past, that no longer represented the school's position.
And then what had transpired with this man's attempt to take a brief course in wood joinery in British Columbia was disseminated in the press, both through the Canadian and Israeli media, and groups representing Israel supporters became involved, contacting the school. The publicity was not of the type usually welcomed by any enterprise set up to educate and to flourish. And it took no time at all for the school's position to change dramatically, inviting Mr. Daron to resend his application.
This represents a general opinion site for its author. It also offers a space for the author to record her experiences and perceptions,both personal and public. This is rendered obvious by the content contained in the blog, but the space is here inviting me to write. And so I do.