"By
2011, she [Charlotte Kates] helped to found Samidoun, which boasts chapters around the
world and has the stated purpose of seeking “to achieve justice for
Palestinian prisoners,” in Israeli detention through demonstrations and
other public events. Earlier this year she travelled to Iran to accept a
human rights award, where it also has a chapter."
"Many
of the prisoners she advocates to be freed have links to “terrorism,
assassinations and countless attacks against Israel,” according to
Public Safety Canada."
"By
listing a group as a terrorist entity, it becomes a crime to provide
them with material support. Leading up to its listing, Kates’
organization had long sparked concern from political leaders and
companies. One point, she told supporters they could only take paper
cheques, in light of the restrictions placed on them."
Stephanie Taylor, National Post
Almost
a year-and-a-half after Samidoun was listed as a designated terrorist
group in Canada, no move has yet been made by any government authority
to disband their Canadian operations. For that period as well Samidoun
retained charitable status with Revenue Canada, continuing to raise
funds in Canada to be sent abroad to Hamas and to the PFLP where
Samidoun's founder Charlotte Kate's husband, Palestinian Khaled Barakat
is a member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. Both
husband and wife, incidentally, have Canadian citizenship.
Anti-Israel protesters at a Samidoun-organized rally burn a Canadian flag outside the Vancouver Art Gallery on October 7, 2024.Photo by Jarryd Jaeger/X
"[It is completely unacceptable [that Samidoun remained a federally registered not-for-profit]."
"I
have therefore directed government officials to urgently look at any
and all options to formally dissolve Samidoun as well as any and all
listed terrorist entities in Canada."
Melanie Joly, Industry Minister, September 2025
Oops,
big splash, but never carried through. Samidoun remains headquartered
in Vancouver. Finally, Corporations Canada pulled Samidoun registration
on March 27, stating that Samidoun, accused not only of advocating for
violent terrorism, but of helping to fundraise for active Gazan terror
groups, took action -- actually no, they did not. A statement on that
very same day by the U.S. Department of the Treasury elaborated more
fully, accusing Samidoun of exploiting the charitable sector to bankroll
extremist violence. A "sham fundraiser whose efforts have supported terrorism".
Samidoun, advocating for Palestinian prisoners...Photo: Fatin al-Tamimi
Samidoun
remained an active listing on Corporations Canada's official database,
including a business number and names and addresses of three Samidoun
directors. The listing eventually had a note appended to warn observers
Corporations Canada was in the process of reviewing details of a
terrorist organization, that any contact with the group might risk
criminal prosecution. "It
is a criminal offence for anyone in Canada ... to directly or
indirectly provide property knowing that it will be used by or benefit a
terrorist group", they alerted.
The
registration remained active and only after a technical violation of
the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act was resolved would their
registration be wiped out. That violation seems to have been that
Samidoun ceased submitting annual filings, following its terror
designation; an oversight that was ultimately responsible for its being "dissolved for non-compliance". Really.
Since
Samidoun's official federal terrorist designation none of its
organizers have faced any charges. Co-founder Charlotte Kates remains
free to enter and exit the country as she wishes. Despite the terror
designation the Samidoun website and social media accounts remain
active. On the website a statement appears that Samidoun intends to
ignore the error designation, where Canada is referred to as a "settler-colonial state built on genocide".
A screenshot of the Samidoun-led anti-Israel protest
outside the Vancouver Art Gallery where Charlotte Kates was arrested,
April 26, 2024.Photo by freepalestinetricitiesbc/Instagram
A Terrorist Group in Canada, Raising Funds for Islamist Jihad
A Palestinian girl stands near a poster of Ibrahim al-Nabulsi, a commander of the
Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigade, one of the main terrorist groups present in
the West Bank operating under the ruling Fatah party, who was killed by
Israeli troops in August 2022. The poster bears the Samidoun logo.
(Photo by JAAFAR ASHTIYEH/AFP via Getty Images)
"Whereas the RCMP announced they had arrested two
suspects in Toronto as they were allegedly about to commit a terrorist
attack for ISIS."
"Whereas Trudeau’s government gave citizenship to an
alleged terrorist with blood on his hands who allegedly dismembered a
body for an ISIS film."
"Whereas Trudeau waited far too long to ban pro-terror
groups like the IRGC, who are responsible for the deaths of thousands
of innocents, including 85 people who called Canada home, and Samidoun,
who are affiliated with and support listed terrorist organizations like
Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine
(PFLP)."
"Whereas Houthi terrorists are still currently allowed to operate, organize, and fundraise in Canada."
"And whereas Justin Trudeau is not serious about
Canada’s national security and disregards the safety of our citizens and
it is now impossible for Canadians to have any faith in the Liberals’
ability to protect our country."
"Therefore, we the undersigned support Pierre
Poilievre and common sense Conservatives in their commitment to secure
our borders, ban pro-terror groups, and keep dangerous terrorists out of
our country."
Parliamentary Opposition Conservative Party of Canada
The
group Samidoun was added to Canada's list of terrorist groups in
October of 2024 under the Criminal Code of Canada. This move by the-then
Liberal government of Justin Trudeau was finally forced on the
government when Canadian flags were being burned at a Samidoun Vancouver
rally honouring the Hamas terrorist group following the Palestinian
terrorist invasion of southern Israel that produced an orgy of sadistic
savagery, raping, mutilating and slaughtering Jewish children, women and
men.
Investigators
and Jewish groups pointed out to the Liberal government Samidoun's ties
to the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, one of Samidoun's
founding members being a leading figure in the PFLP which was already
outlawed and on Canada's terror list. Samidoun leading a demonstration
chanting "Death to Canada"
while burning a Canadian flag did not endear the group to Canadians
other than those who found merit in lionizing Palestinian terrorism.
What
is inexplicable is that some eight months have passed since Samidoun
was placed on the terrorist list, but the group, based in Vancouver and
linked to other groups which have roiled the streets of Canada's cities
in ongoing violent displays of anti-Israel, pro-Hamas support, taking
over major intersections in mass prayer sessions symbolic of Islamist
conquest, have continued their hateful messages of Intifada, 'From the
River to the Sea', and 'Final Solution', without restraint by any
government agency or regional police forces.
A photo shows a flag of the organization 'Samidoun' during a
"in solidarity with Gaza" demonstration in Duisburg, western Germany,
on October 9, 2023. (Photo by INA FASSBENDER/AFP via Getty Images
And
nor has the group's registration as a non-profit, able to continue
raising charitable funds for Islamist terror groups like the PLFP and
Hamas been interrupted. Continuing to operate openly in Canada despite
its affiliations and activities, Samidoun makes a mockery of Canadian
law. Its key figures such as co-founders Charlotte Kates and her husband
Khaled Barakat go about their business of leading protests in honour of
October 7 and the courageous terrorists who murdered 1,200 Jews, as
'revolutionaries' against the 'occupation' of Palestine by Israel whom
they label criminal genocidaires.
Despite publicly declaring "I am here to express the views of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine",
no legal action has been taken against Khaled Barakat who has been
instrumental in establishing terrorist cells in the West Bank and areas
of the West. Proudly and publicly lauding Hamas as "heroic and brave",
his wife Kates attended the funeral of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah
in Beirut last year. The visited Iran where she was bestowed with a
'humanitarian' medal in recognition of her work on behalf of the Islamic
Republic.
During
the October 7 slaughter of Israelis in southern Israel, some Canadians
were victims of the Hamas incursion. Family members of October 7 victims
in Canada filed a lawsuit against terrorists, one that includes
Samidoun, Kates and Barakat. Samidoun is labelled a sham charity in the
U.S., outlawed in Germany and the Netherlands, yet the government of
Canada, while performatively placing it on a terror list, allows it
continued charitable status, to fundraise in support of Hamas, in
Canada.
Charlotte
Kates, a co-founder of Vancouver-based Samidoun, which has been
declared a terrorist entity by the Canadian government, poses for a
photo at the funeral of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah in Lebanon in
February 2025.Photo by @charlottekates/X
In Its Own Words: Hamas is a Palestinian Islamic Liberation and Resistance Movement Whose Goal is to Liberate Palestine and Confront the Zionist Project
"It's
an honour to have contributed to this critically important application
... against the criminalization of Palestinian resistance in Britain,
the imperial power responsible for Zionist colonialism in Palestine."
"[Aiding and assisting on request an application to de-list Hamas in the U.K. as a] proscribed/banned [terror group]."
Charlotte Kates, leader, Samidoun
"The British government’s decision to proscribe Hamas is an unjust one
that is symptomatic of its unwavering support for Zionism, apartheid,
occupation, and ethnic cleansing in Palestine for over a century."
"Hamas does not and never has posed a threat to Britain,
despite the latter’s ongoing complicity in the genocide of our people."
"Hamas
is] a Palestinian Islamic liberation and resistance movement whose goal
is to liberate Palestine and confront the Zionist project."
Legal Petition to the United Kingdom by Hamas
"The legal profession is being damaged by ideologues exploiting their
status to platform extremism."
"This isn’t about free speech. It’s about a man [Riverway Law attorney Fahad Ansari], who
repeatedly crosses the line into open support for terrorism — all while
the authorities look away."
British Shadow Justice Secretary Robert Jenrick
"They pose an ongoing threat to our security and to the peace and
stability of the Middle East and have weapons and training facilities
that put lives at risk and threaten our interests."
"They show no respect for human rights, life, and dignity and
have oppressed people living in Gaza for too long."
"Those campaigning to end the proscription of Hamas fail to
understand the seriousness of the threats this terrorist organization
poses."
"[Hamas is an] evil Iranian-backed terrorist organization, which kidnaps,
tortures, and murders people, including British nationals."
Shadow Foreign Secretary Priti Patel
Demonstrators hold Israeli and British flags outside the Law Courts,
during a march against antisemitism, after an increase in the UK, during
a temporary truce between the Palestinian Islamist terrorists Hamas and
Israel, in London, Britain, Nov. 26, 2023. Photo: REUTERS/Susannah
Ireland
The
United Kingdom classified the 'military wing' of Hamas as a terror
organization in 2001; a definition expanded two decades later to
encompass the entire organization, including the political arm. Hamas
encourages the West to think of it as a legitimate group fighting
oppression, with distinct arms: a Health Authority, a political wing, a
military wing and an executive body. In reality Hamas itself scoffs
derisively at the very thought that there are such executive divisions;
they consider the entire group as single-mindedly focused and engaged in
its singular purpose: the destruction of the State of Israel.
A
legal group by the name of Riverway Law which is supporting Hamas in
its application to the U.K. government for the terrorist designation to
be rescinded, contacted Charlotte Kates, herself head of a
Vancouver-based outfit that advertises itself as a support for
Palestinian prisoners in Israeli prisons, and which advocates as well
for the legalization of Hamas and other terrorist groups as 'freedom
fighters' and is part of a group proscribed in Canada as a terrorist
entity.
One
of Samidoun's leaders, Kates's husband, has direct links to the Popular
Front for the Liberation of Palestine as a leading figure within it,
another terrorist group that is proscribed as such in Canada. Riverway
Law contacted Kates with a request for an "expert report" representing
Samidoun that she and her husband co-founded, and Kates we happy to
comply, as an ardent supporter of Hamas in Canada. Notorious for leading
public chants of "Long Live October 7!"
It
is such an honor to be here in Beirut today, one among a sea of over a
million people in collective tribute, mourning, love and commitment to
the road of resistance and liberation exemplified by Sayyed Hassan
Nasrallah and Sayyed Hisham Safieddine. Kates on X
According to Kates, the savage atrocities in Israel were "heroic and brave".
So committed is she that she attended Hezbollah leader Hassan
Nasrallah's public funeral that took place in Lebanon in February,
memorializing him as a "great
anti-imperialist leader of our day, the great Arab and international
revolutionary, the beloved speaker of truth and warrior of justice".
A Hamas political leader, Mousa Abu Marzouk, who lives in Qatar, rejected charges of antisemitism: "Our
struggle against the Jews is very great and very serious. Our struggle
is not against Jewish people because of their religion but against the
Zionists who occupy Palestine. Hamas is of the view that the Jewish
problem of antisemitism and the persecution of the Jews are phenomena
fundamentally linked to European history and not to the history of the
Arabs and the Muslims or to their heritage", he wrote in a witness statement to the Riverway application.
"[Hamas's
terror listing runs]contrary to the European Court of Human Rights [and
is] disproportionate" , wrote the Riverway Law application addressed to
U.K. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper as they were "instructed by Hamas" to do. "The reality is that [Hamas] poses no threat to the U.K. people and have been explicit about this" -- handily bypassing the 15 British nationals who were slaughtered in the October 7 southern Israel attack in 2023.
"A
whole host of legal and mental gymnastics were provided by the head of
the law firm to explain why their actions are legitimate and how this is
somehow a valid pathway to ending the bloodshed in Gaza and responding
to the daily scenes of murdered Palestinian children."
"None
of these individuals, including those at the law firm, bothered to
understand that Hamas is the very root of the destruction of Gaza and
the collapse of the Palestinian national project, having served the
interests of the far right and the anti-Palestinian forces within
Israeli politics and society."
Palestinian American researcher Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib
The Islamist Mainstreaming of Antisemitism Across Canada
"There's been a long history of concern about Al-Quds Day, which is an annual hateful protest, an event that calls for the elimination and eradication of the State of Israel."
"That often ends up bringing out folks who are glorifying terrorists and waving Hamas flags and calling for the death of Jews, and I think in a country like Canada, that is morally objectionable."
Toronto city councillor Brad Bradford
"Many people who grew up there do not recognize the city anymore."
"They are shocked and disheartened by the hate and threats that's taken over in many aspects of day-to-day life, particularly targeting the Jewish community."
"The rallies are nothing more than hate gatherings."
James Pasternak, Toronto city councillor
"Sights like these [Hamas-supporting mobs], are no longer uncommon because Canada's Liberal government has refused to stand against even the most vile behaviour happening in plain view."
"Our Canadian values are under attack right before our eyes -- pretending not to see it is simply shameful."
Deputy Conservative party leader Melissa Lantsman
"In the past, Al-Quds Day rallies, particularly in Toronto, have crossed the line into promotion of hate, antisemitism and support for designated terrorist organizations."
"I will be asking the Mayor of Montreal and police to ensure that all federal and provincial laws and municipal bylaws are strictly enforced and that police have a clear plan to do this and will immediately step in the second the line into illegality is crossed."
Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather
Another annual Al-Quds Day across the country is planned for Sunday. Like all such previous events, it is anticipated the rallies will be rife with antisemitic chants that glorify terrorism. Politicians and community leaders, given the number and frequency of similar rallies that have taken place across Canada for the past year and a half following the October 7, 2023, rampage of deadly violence against Israeli civilians in farming communities in southern Israel that killed 1,200 children, women and men, saw organized 'protests' in support not of the victims of the deadly attack, but the Palestinians responsible for the savagery who portray themselves as the victims.
Those familiar with the events and who deplore them for their celebration and support of deadly violence are warning civil society and taking measures to ensure that law enforcement be prepared to protect the Jewish Canadian community which has been ceaselessly targeted by antisemitism through organized marches and demonstrations, many of which take place deliberately in Jewish-majority enclaves of Canadian cities.
Typically, the events take place toward the end of the Islamic holiday of Ramadan. They materialized in 1979 following the Iranian Revolution when Iran's Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini -- whose Islamist ideology has created Shiite terrorist groups like Hezbollah and the Yemeni Houthis, arming, training and focusing them on the destruction of Israel -- adopted the idea of the "liberation" of Jerusalem [Al-Quds in Arabic]. The demonstrations that take place globally call for "Death to Israel", "Death to America", while effigies and flags are burned.
"Al-Quds Day is not just another protest or demonstration."
"It is a state-sponsored, anti-Israel event, orchestrated annually by the Iranian regime to support the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps [IRGC] -- a Canadian-listed terrorist organization -- in its efforts to destabilize the Middle East and spread hatred against Israel, Jews, and Western democratic values around the world."
The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs
Large rallies for the Al-Quds Day marches have been planned across Canada, in Toronto, Calgary, Vancouver and Montreal. Astonishingly, in the past decade, immigration, refugee intake and illegal migration has given Canada large populations of Muslims from the Middle East and North Africa. The Palestinian Youth Movement is featured in posters for the Toronto and Montreal rallies, a group that supports the October 7 terror attacks. Samidoun, a group designated as a terror entity by the federal government is still permitted to organize events such as these in Canada without demur from the Federal Liberal government.
Toronto city councillors James Pasternak and Brad Bradford have demanded that the city and Toronto police enforce the Hate Rallies policy to protect the Jewish community and ensure 'every necessary precaution is taken'. There is frustration with the mainstreaming of antisemitism across the Greater Toronto Area since the invasion by Hamas of Israel on October 7, 2023.
An Al-Quds Day rally in Toronto, 2014.Photo by YouTube/Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center
"As with all demonstrations and large gatherings, police will be there to ensure public safety."
"In addition to a visible frontline officer presence, we will also have officers from our specialized Hate Crime Unit on the ground, to immediately gather evidence and investigate any suspected hate crimes, or hate speech, or signage."
Toronto Police Service spokeswoman Stephanie Sayer
"[Samidoun,
also known as Palestinian Prisoner Solidarity Network], claims to be
campaigning for the release of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails."
"Many
Palestinian prisoners for which Samidoun advocates for release have
ties to terrorism, assassinations and countless attacks against Israel."
"Samidoun's
ideology revolves exclusively around the worldview that Israel and
Zionism are the greatest danger to the Middle East and the world."
Public Safety Canada
"The Vancouver Police Major Crime Section, with assistance from the
Vancouver Police Department Emergency Response Team, executed a search warrant yesterday at a
residence in the 1800 block of East 1st Avenue, as part of an ongoing
hate crime investigation under Section 319 of the Criminal Code."
"One person was initially taken into custody and has now been released pending completion of the investigation."
VPD media spokesperson Tania Visintin
Social media posts from pro-Palestinian activists supporting Kates and
Samidoun expressed outrage and questioned the “excessive” police
presence involved in the Nov. 14 raid (top left, via Global News) to
execute a search warrant in a public incitement of hatred investigation.
(Via Instagram)
"At times, the community [Vancouver and wider B.C. Jewish community] feels alone… Jewish businesses have been
targeted, Jewish members of the community have been targeted in schools,
at university, in the workplace."
"We have seen the glorification of
terrorism at the hands of members of Samidoun [including at weekly
protests on the steps of the Vancouver Art Gallery]."
"[The community is feeling] threatened and unsafe."
"We believe that it is crucial for civil society that Charlotte Kates
be charged immediately. She’s now the leader of a terror organization."
"Let the courts decide."
Nico Slobinsky, vice-president, Pacific Region, Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs
Since
the Palestinian terrorists' attack on southern Israel led by Hamas in
Gaza on October 7, 2023, Samidoun, along with other Palestinian agitprop
group have been inciting to violent antisemitism in the guise of
criticizing 'Zionism', and organizing ongoing weekly and sometimes daily
marches, protests and groups harassing Jewish communities and
Jewish-owned businesses. Crowds of Palestinian-flag-waving antisemites
have gathered outside hospitals, old-age retirement homes, synagogues,
Jewish schools and community centres to shout invectives and threats
against Israel veiled with 'From the River to the sea".
Clearly
antisocial verging on psychopathic activities like blocking streets
and highways with marchers shouting 'Intifada!' and 'Final Solution'
have inspired no reaction by authorities at any level, anywhere across
the country. Jews are left to fend for themselves against the risen tide
of antisemitism, viral in its endless permutations of isolation and
hate-messaging. The federal government, much less provincial or
municipal authorities have been satisfied to sit back and 'not notice'
that a cultural/ethnic/religious minority in Canada's equal society with
its guarantees of security for all, have been besieged for over a year.
And
then when it became obvious that Jews were the appetizer, and once that
went down well, the main course would commence, when Palestinian,
pro-Hamas groups and organizers turned on Canada itself as a purportedly
racist, colonialist, imperialist country perched on land not their own,
taken by force from its original denizens, and shouts of derogatory
derision damning Canada along with the attempted burning of a Canadian
flag by Samidoun supporters moved the government to finally outlaw
Samidoun as a terrorist group, closely aligned with the
already-designated Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
Despite
Samidoun being listed as a terrorist organization in Canada last month,
its co-founder and director Charlotte Kates has been proceeding with
the group, continuing to organize marches that demonize Israel, calling
for its destruction, and threatening Canadian Jews' security, with no
moves by either the Federal government or law and order to step in and
put a halt to those activities. Listing Samidoun as a terrorist entity
was a first step, but it seemed that following through to stop its
activities was a step too far.
Now,
finally, the Vancouver home of Charlotte Kates, out of which the
management of the Samidoun group and its many branches abroad is
located, was raided by the Vancouver Police Department's Emergency
Response Team. A search warrant was executed relating to a hate crime
investigation. During the raid, a flash-bang grenade was used, resulting
in windows of the house being broken. It was explained by a police
spokesperson that the emergency response team is "often used in the execution of search warrants when we believe there could be a risk to the public or a risk to the officers".
Time
for justice and the Canadian court system to work in tandem with the
police departments of the nation, in coordination with government,
serious about condemning racism and terrorism and putting a halt to its
expansion within Canada.
Samidoun: Offended It is Recognized as a Terrorist Group
"[Between
the three politicians [Public Safety Minister Dominic LeBlanc, Prime
Minister Justin Trudeau and Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre]
recklessly and maliciously [accusing Samidoun as a terrorist entity
owing a retraction and apology, a lawsuit has gone forward]."
"The suit will force the biggest mouths in government to actually show proof of the allegation of terrorist activity."
"It
is very dangerous if we allow a government to decide who gets to enjoy
full rights and who doesn't without showing actual proof."
Toronto lawyer Stephen Ellis
"The Liberals cannot legislate away our right to free speech."
"If they contend we are terrorists, let them prove it in court."
Charlotte Kates, co founder, Samidoun
"Samidoun
does not have any material or organizational ties to entities listed on
the terrorist lists of the United States, Canada or the European
Union."
Samidoun statement
Anti-Israel demonstrators march in Ottawa on March 9,
2024. Samidoun, a group listed in Israel as a terror organization and
banned outright in Germany, is one of the main groups organizing
pro-Palestinian protests in Canada.Photo by Ashley Fraser / Postmedia
Vancouver-based
Samidoun established a global network of support branches to which they
give direction in the promulgation of 'public relations' announcements
and protests in support of Palestinian 'rights' and entitlements in a
world where Palestinian terrorism wreaks havoc as it mounts terrorist
assaults against Jews universally and within Israel in particular,
exacting a penalty of murder as the price it feels Israel must pay for
its insistence that it has a right to exist on its own ancestral land.
Palestinian
terrorism is geared toward penalizing Israel and Jews through a
never-ending devotion to lethal assaults against their 'oppressor'.
Portraying themselves as victims seeking restitution of land they claim
as theirs despite that it is historically Judean land, and Jews the
original inhabitants native to the land, those identifying themselves as
'Palestinians' are in fact looting from the indigenous Jewish
population the heritage that was never theirs.
There
is, and never has been, a shortage of militant terrorism among the Arab
Palestinian population. Among the earliest and most barbaric has been
the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, involved in plane and
sea-going vessel hijacking, hostage-taking and murderous assaults.
Samidoun is a later, public-relations manifestation of Palestinian
terrorism's realization of what can be accomplished when slanderous lies
are repeated frequently enough to seem believable to the
history-ignorant West.
Samidoun,
ostensibly created to speak for the rights of Palestinians in Israeli
prisons serving sentences for violent crimes against Israelis -- to
agitate for their recognition as 'freedom fighters' eligible for release
by virtue of the fact that whatever crimes were committed were in
defense of their right to 'struggle against' their colonialist
oppressors -- is committed to portraying violent criminals as merely
asserting their humanitarian right to free themselves from imperialist
colonizers.
Protesters from the
Samidoun organization gather in front of the Muelheim train
station in Cologne, Germany, on April 15, 2023, to commemorate
Palestinian Prisoners' Day (Ying Tang / NurPhoto via Getty Images)
Those
like Charlotte Kates preach to a public in the West for whom
antisemitism is not unknown, that there is a connection between
colonizers of the past and those of the present, as despised,
indigenous-injurious exploiters of original, authentic territorial
populations. Not only do they promote chants of 'death to Israel', but
also 'death to Canada', tarred with the same colonizing brush as Israel.
Samidoun portrays itself as a human-rights group seeking justice for
all disentitled people, with a special emphasis on Jews and Israel, its
first and foremost agenda.
Its
links with the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine are
obvious enough, not least since the other of its co-founders, Kates's
husband Khaled Barakat, is a prominent leader in the PFLP. Kates has run
afoul of Canada's hate-speech prohibitions in law, with Vancouver
Police leading an investigation following on her having fulsomely
praised the savage Hamas attack in southern Israel on October 7, 2023.
Jewish groups in Canada have identified Samidoun for what it is,
lobbying government to have it recognized as a hate group and enabler of
terrorism; linked in its formation and purpose with an already-listed
terror group, the PFLP.
Several
weeks back, no longer able to ignore the reality of Samidoun's purpose,
linkages and incitements the federal government finally relented and
announced its decision to place Samidoun on the country's terror list.
With the kind of impudent, defiant arrogance recognizable as a hallmark
of Samidoun, it now portrays itself as ill done by, a victim of
government over-reach, and should apologies not be forthcoming, a
full-scale lawsuit is to be mounted.
The
leader of the official opposition in Parliament, Pierre Poilievre, had
called on the Liberals to designate Samidoun as a terror entity,
emphasizing that the group had "clear and direct ties"
to designated terror groups abroad. Mr. Poilievre stated, before the
official announcement of its designation, that prime minister Trudeau
and the federal New Democratic Party "have allowed terrorist organizations to operate freely across Canada", which qualified him a place alongside Canada's public safety minister and prime minister in the pending lawsuit.
A screenshot of the Samidoun-led anti-Israel protest
outside the Vancouver Art Gallery where Charlotte Kates was arrested,
April 26, 2024.Photo by freepalestinetricitiesbc/Instagram
Finally Placing Samidoun on the U.S./Canada Terror List
"His
[Khaled Barakat, Samidoun founder] fundraising and recruitment efforts
support the PFLP's terrorist activity against Israel."
"[The
United States is designating Samidoun a] sham charity that serves as an
international fundraiser for the Popular Front for the Liberation of
Palestine [PFLP] terrorist organization."
"The
PFLP, which was designated as a Foreign Terrorist Organization and a
Specially Designated Global Terrorist by the U.S. Department of State in
October 1997 and October 2001, respectively, uses Samidoun to maintain
fundraising operations in both Europe and North America."
U.S. State Department press release
"Organizations
like Samidoun masquerade as charitable actors that claim to provide
humanitarian support to those in need, yet in reality divert funds for
much-needed assistance to support terrorist groups."
Acting Under-Secretary of the Treasury for Terrorism and Financial Intelligence, Bradley T. Smith
Charlotte Kates, in Tehran two weeks ago, accepts the Iranian human right award Iran International
The
Vancouver-based anti-Israel organization has finally been listed by
Canada, after much campaigning by Canadian Jewish groups, some
pro-Israel-supporting Members of Parliament and editorials in a number
of Canadian newspapers. What finally forced the Trudeau Liberal
government to act was not the terrorist charity's organization of
hundreds of rallies and protests decrying Israel's very existence while
making life dangerous for Jews in Canada through its incitements of
hate, but the over-reach by Samidoun revealing the scope of its program.
When
the hate group encouraged and guided its followers to declare
themselves fully in support of Hamas and Hezbollah, declaring fealty to
the Islamic Republic of Iran, the Houthis, Hamas, Hezbollah and other
non-government terrorist militias from Iraq and Syria to Lebanon and
Gaza, insisting that 'imperial-colonialist' Canada must be defeated, and
burning a Canadian flag to emphasize their point, prime minister Justin
Trudeau no longer had any excuse to hide behind failing to recognize
them for what they are.
"The
listing of Samidoun as a terrorist entity under the Criminal Code sends
a strong message that Canada will not tolerate this type of activity,
and will do everything in its power to counter the ongoing threat to
Canada's national security and all people in Canada",
announced Public Safety Minister Dominic LeBlanc. It remains to be seen
just how strenuously committed this government will be to 'do everything
in its power' to destroy the malevolent effect this terror group has
succeeded in producing in Canada, in its goal of destabilization and
conquest.
Unbelievably,
the group has enjoyed charitable status in Canada for years, long after
it was repeatedly brought to the attention of the government that their
activities created stark and dangerous divisions within Canadian
society with no end in sight to their ambitious agenda of making Canada
terror-central to the Palestinian networks of demonizing Israel, calling
for its destruction, and hounding Jewish Canadians in public, while
inciting to violence against Jewish institutions in Canada.
The
US. government went a step further than Canada, in designating
Barakat's wife Charlotte Kates, a director of Samidoun, a terrorist,
while Khaled Barakat himself has been identified as a ranking
leadership member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
These Palestinian terrorist stalwarts last week organized a rally on the
one-year anniversary of the October 7 terror attacks where attendees
chanted "death to Canada", to which Samidoun later announced "we at Samidoun stand by this phrase as the call to action that it is".
Masked protesters set a Canadian flag on fire at the event, while a woman led chants of "We are Hezbollah and we are Hamas";
identifying with Lebanon and Gaza. The PFLP has been listed by Canada
as a terrorist organization since 2003. Groups with a terrorist
designation are prohibited from receiving financial services, donations
of money, or property.
Kates,
who directly following the October 7 southern Israel atrocities
perpetrated by Palestinian terrorists led by Hamas, praised the Hamas
and Islamic Jihad savages at a rally: "We stand with the Palestinian resistance and their heroic brave action on October 7",
she crowed. The Vancouver Police Department launched a hate-speech
investigation as a follow-up to that event. It has been over year that
the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs lobbied government for Samidoun
to be declared a terrorist organization, launching a petition with
B'nai Brith Canada to have Kates and Barakat deported.
Screenshot showing the Facebook page of Samidoun Deutschland. November 03, 2023. (credit: SEAN GALLUP/GETTY IMAGES
"This
process has not been tested in Canadian courts. A lot of the reason for
that is because we are designating, for the most part, foreign
entities. This is one of the only cases where I've seen a direct
Canadian tie and a direct Canadian leader ... who will be directly
affected by a terrorist listing."
"In
the case of an organization like Samidoun, or really any listed
terrorist entity, the question comes down to what the people are doing
to support the organization."
"Just
being a member of an organization is not a criminal offence in Canada.
However, as soon as you cross the line into conducting any kind of
support or sort of advancement activities that are fairly concrete,
then you come very close to facilitation [of a terrorist activity] and
some of those activities."
Jessica Davis, counterterrorism expert, Carleton University
"[T]he
plaintiffs plead that the Samidoun Defendants have committed offences
including, but not limited to, providing or collecting property for
terrorist activity, providing or collecting property for the benefit of
persons facilitating or carrying out terrorist activity, participating
in the activity of a terrorist group, leaving Canada to participate in
the activity of a terrorist group, and facilitating terrorist activity."
Statement of Claim in Ontario Superior Court of Justice
"[Criteria
enabling the federal government to list a terrorist entity is if the
person or group in question has] knowingly acted on behalf of, at the
direction of or in association with an entity that has knowingly carried
out, attempted to carry out, participated in or facilitated a terrorist
activity."
Canada's Criminal Code
"Samidoun
is knowingly acting on behalf of, at the direction of or in association
with the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a terrorist
group under the Criminal Code."
"This qualifies Samidoun for a terrorist listing."
"Why hasn't this happened?"
Conservative foreign affairs critic Michael Chong
"These are resistance fighters."
"These are our heroes. These are those who are sacrificing so that we can live and speak and struggle and fight."
"These are the people whose blood is being shed to defend humanity and to defend the world."
Charlotte Kates, international coordinator for Samidoun
"The
expiration of her conditions of release will allow her to continue to
initiate hate and division against the local Jewish community."
"If
we value respect, inclusion, and diversity the Crown must approve and
lay the charges recommended by the Vancouver Police Department."
Ezra Shanken, CEO, Jewish Federation of Greater Vancouver
Samidoun,
a clearly terrorist-supporting group that has established itself in
Vancouver with branches elsewhere across Canada, has declared itself a
solidarity network for Palestinian prisoners. Its founder, Khaled
Barakat, married to Charlotte Kates, Samidoun leader, also happens to be
identified as a senior figure in the Popular Front for the Liberation
of Palestine, itself a listed terrorist organization in Canada, the
U.S., Israel, the U.K. and the European Union. Yet this group that has
been at the forefront of organizing countless pro-Hamas demonstrations
across Canada, enjoys charitable status in Canada.
And
irrespective of its representation of a proscribed terrorist group
listed as such in Canada, the federal Liberal government refuses to
address the issue of allowing such a group to operate in Canada, despite
the social upheaval it has been part of, in demonizing Israel and
harassing Jewish Canadians. There are, in fact, Muslim Members of
Parliament at the ministerial level that had signed a contract with
Khaled Barakat to conduct instructive human rights sessions for various
government departments, until it was revealed that the man had a
background linked to terrorism.
The
Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine has an established record
of having pioneered the carrying out of assassinations, suicide
bombings, hijackings and murders. Shortly following Germany expelling
Kates and Barakat, they established Samidoun in Vancouver as the
headquarters of its global operation. A number of Members of Parliament
have called upon the federal government to designate Samidoun for what
it is, a terrorist organization. Muslim MPs will resist that, and the
Trudeau Liberals will not go out of their way to alienate the large and
growing Muslim-Canadian demographic, since it's a poor vote-garnering
technique.
At
a Samidoun-organized commemoration of the glories of the October 7,
2023 slaughter of 1,200 Israelis, the savage mass rape of Israeli girls
and women, their pitiless mutilation and torture, and the abduction of
250 Israeli children, elderly, women and girls on its one-year
anniversary when protesters burned the Canadian flag while chanting
'death to Canada', 'death to the United States', and "we are Hezbollah and we are Hamas", declaring 'Death to Israel'.
Samidoun was 'mourning' the death of Hamas's leader, Hassan Nasrallah, vowing its intention to continue its "...jihadist path [and] follow [Nasrallah's] methodology".
While Justin Trudeau's government has failed to advance remedial action
against the rancid antisemitism that Samidoun and other pro-Hamas
groups in Canada relish exhibiting in the public arena, Canada's
Conservative Opposition Leader Pierre Poilievre vows that when he
becomes prime minister he will quickly intervene to declare Samidoun an
outlawed terrorist group.
In a still of a video posted online, protesters at a pro-Palestinian
rally are seen burning a Canadian flag as some chant 'death to Canada,
death to the United States and death to Israel.' (Jarryd Jäger/Western Standard)
"So,
if burning a Canadian flag, if calling for the death of Canadians, if
fomenting hate in this country and most of all being a front for an
already-listed terrorist organization is not enough to put them on the
[federal government's terrorist] list, then what the hell is it going to
take for them to ban them?"
"Back then, you simply did not see people running through the streets saying, I'm an al-Qaeda supporter, I love bin Laden."
"When I look at what's going on now, that's the important thing, in my mind [open expressions of support for terrorist groups]."
"It's
very different now. With the Toronto 18 [homegrown terror group], we
had a small group of people, some of whom had known each other for a
while, and they built their little group and they did it in secret."
"They didn't have these massive demonstrations where like-minded people can easily identify one another."
Former RCMP counterterrorism investigator John Mecher
"We are very concerned."
Samidoun
is known to be directly linked to the Popular Front for the Liberation
of Palestine, which is already a listed terrorist organization [in
Canada and elsewhere]."
"They
have been inciting and glorifying terrorist attacks and massacres since
October 7. They were already hanging signs from bridges in Vancouver."
"This is a serious source of concern."
Israeli Ambassador to Canada Ido Moed
"These are resistance fighters. These are our heroes."
"These are those who are sacrificing so that we can live and speak and struggle and fight."
"These are the people whose blood is being shed to defend humanity and to defend the world."
"We stand with the Palestinian resistance and their heroic and brave action on October 7."
"Long live October 7!"
Charlotte Kates, international co-ordinator for the Samidoun Prisoners Solidarity Network
Charlotte Kates spoke at a demonstration on the steps of the Vancouver
Art Gallery last Friday. Her comments have led to a hate crime
investigation by the Vancouver Police Department. (B'nai Brith Canada)
Samidoun
is one of the major groups responsible for dozens of 'pro-Palestine'
rallies and demonstrations that have appeared in Canada since the
October 7 Hamas atrocities perpetrated on civilians in southern Israel.
It was those savage acts of terror that included mass rapes, torching
family homes with parents and children inside, mutilation of female
victims, mass murders and hostage-taking of children, women and the
elderly that led to Israel launching its military against Hamas to
destroy its infrastructure and eliminate its terrorist operatives.
Openly and with a sense of profound entitlement "Long live October 7"
was the slogan chanted at the Vancouver Art Gallery last Friday and in
Ottawa at yet another April 21 rally on Parliament Hill. Where Kates
gushed about the "beautiful, brave and heroic resistance of the Palestinian people".
She has no hesitation in addressing her concerns directly to
Parliament. Little wonder -- at one time her husband was on contract
with Heritage Canada to teach public servants how to deal with racism.
"It
is long past time to delist Palestinian and Lebanese resistance
organizations [Hamas and Hezbollah] from Canada's so-called list of
terrorist entities."
"Hamas
is not a terrorist organization. Islamic Jihad is not a terrorist
organization. The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine is not a
terrorist organization."
Hezbollah is not a terrorist organization."
Charlotte Kates, Samidoun
Banned
in Germany for its links to terrorism and its blatant antisemitism
along with its illegal activities, Samidoun, based now in Vancouver
while terror-listed in Israel, has been intimately associated with the
PFLP, once notorious for its suicide bombings and airline hijacking
exploits. An internal dispute among 'pro-Palestine' activists at Rutgers
University in New Jersey, saw this woman arrive in Canada some dozen
years ago.
She
is also the coordinator of the U.S. National Lawyers' Guild's
International Committee whose member-lawyers expend enormous time and
energy acting pro bono for 'pro-Palestine' protests and encampments at
universities across the United States. Her husband, Khaled Barakat, born
in Dahiyat al-Barid, a village near Jerusalem in 1971 was deported from
the U.S. after an expired residency permit leading him to Vancouver as a
student activist at the University of British Columbia in 2004.
Barakat
has been identified by the Israeli Shin Bet security service as a
senior figure in the PFLP, the primary leader of Samidoun, the PFLP's
overseas recruitment propaganda proxy. His tendency to violent,
antisemitic rhetoric led to his being deported from Europe; both
husband and wife are now barred from reentering Europe. Shockingly,
Samidoun has been given federally registered not-for-profit status in
Canada.
Former
RCMP counterterrorism investigator John Mecher is of the opinion that
Ottawa should be taking Samidoun seriously, that it may be only a matter
of time before Hamas and its Canadian supporters spawn a new generation
of homegrown extremists. The current phenomenon of 'pro-Palestine'
activism represents, he feels, a far greater risk of recruitment to
violent extremism and terrorism than was present in the radical activist
situation that prevailed in the wake of 9/11.
Charlotte Kates (top left) and Khaled Barakat (top right) spoke at an
online forum organized by Columbia university students which later led
to a series of suspensions by the university. (@thestustustudio/X)
"On October 7, we saw the potential for a Palestine liberated from Zionism by the forces of the resistance."
"[Demonstration
attendees should make an effort] to live up to the examples that every
fighter in the brigades [Hamas, PLFP, PIJ, etc.] and every Yemeni marine
[Houthis] are showing on a daily basis."
Charlotte Kates, leader, Samidoun/People's Liberation Front for Palestine
"[Officers attending these protests] have been threatened with injury or death."
"Last weekend, a woman threw horse feces at our our officers, and another woman used a flagpole to spear at others."
"[Female police officers report] being targeted at these events in ways their male colleagues are not."
"Officers
were at the Eaton's Centre to respond to a protest where threats were
directed to a member of the public, not to police."
"[Officers] are working each day to ensure protests do not escalate & we are grateful for their efforts."
Toronto Police Association [union]
Anti-Israel protesters outside Toronto's city hall on Saturday, April 6, 2024.Photo by X
In
Canada, in Toronto, which has seen hundreds of 'pro-Palestinian',
pro-Hamas rallies take place, where cries of 'Intifada', "From the river
to the sea", 'Final Solution' and other pointedly hate-consuming
epithets ring out, all of them a threat by their very nature, and
directed against Canadian Jews, the police and government officials,
federal, provincial and municipal, while decrying the violence, have
done little to uphold the law against threats and violence by masked
perpetrators.
Finally,
when the crowds have become rowdier, more vehemently vicious and begin
to target the police themselves standing by to maintain order, police
begin to react. It's one thing threatening Jews directly, attacking
their synagogues, hospitals, private businesses, parochial schools and
social centres, but expressing foul-mouthed threats against police and
insults and violence directed toward the sentries of public order and
security has gone one too far, evidently.
This
past weekend in Toronto saw an uprise in terrorist-supporting rhetoric.
Outlawed in Germany as a recognized terrorist group, Samidoun, with its
direct links to violent terrorist groups with blood on their hands, and
itching to increase that blood count, was up front and centre with one
of its major leaders directing members of the protest to emulate Middle
East terrorist groups and do it right here, in Canada, in Toronto, the
city with the largest population of Canadian Jews. No censure, no
comment from Justin Trudeau, Canada's witless prime minister.
On the Saturday terror-rally a sign reading "Hamas is a Palestinian Resistance Movement"
was held by a child at Toronto's Nathan Phillips Square, among a small
crowd of protesters present for the purpose of opposing a pro-Israel
rally where Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre was featured and where
he would express his unalloyed support of Israel and dedication as
future Prime Minister to the safety and security of Jewish Canadians.
Beside the child stood a man with a microphone, who addressed the Jewish attendees of the event: "It's
so wonderful to see all the little kids here ... ask your parents to
give you a history lesson about how they rape and murder children",
he boomed at people who would forever mourn the dread October 7
bloodbath that Palestinian terrorists imposed on southern Israel when
Jewish children were raped and slaughtered by terrorists who as children
were taught at UNRWA schools to hate Jews and relish killing them.
That
Canada lists Hamas as a terrorist group, and is technically in conflict
with the Houthis in Yemen which has been busy attacking shipping in the
Red Sea, yet both are being cited as models of 'resistance' against
'Zionists' by a radicalized terror-supporter in public, at a Square in
Toronto named after a once-mayor and prominent Jewish Canada, seems to
raise no concerns over hate-promulgation from any level of government
leadership.
There
was an image of the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem as a backdrop to
Samidoun's chief hate-monger, surrounded by a Star of David constructed
of barbed wire. This was a celebration of Al Quds Day, a 'holiday' that
then-supreme leader Ruhollah Khomeni conceived in 1979 following the
Iranian Revolution. A day of anti-Israel and terror-promoting
demonstrations regularly taking place in Canada's cities. Fulfilling
their destiny, hate groups like Toronto4Palestine happily busied
themselves organizing October 7 massacres with utter impunity.
"If
they're going to break the law, if they're going to assault our police
horses, there will be consequences and people will be arrested."
"Agitators [within the demonstrations would not be tolerated]."
Deputy Chief Lauren Pogue, Ottawa Police Service
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre arrives
to speak to over 2,000 pro-Israel supporters gathered at Nathan Philips
Square to mark 6 months since the deadly Hamas attack on Oct. 7.
"Israel
was established after its neighbours rejected a United Nations plan to
partition the land between Jews and Arabs. As it was founded, [Israel]
joined the United Nations in 1949. The legitimacy of Israel as a Jewish
state is completely insusceptible to question, and the attempt to
represent it as entirely a wrongful occupation of anyone else's
territory is not even slightly sustainable."
"The
Jews have transformed a primitive country in one lifetime into a
sophisticated and prosperous democratic state where the deserts now
bloom, and [as] a nuclear power."
"The
Jews have been in what is now Israel for more than 5,000 years. The
Phoenicians, Jews, Egyptians, Syrians, Persians, Macedonians, Seleucids
Romans, Byzantines, Arabians, Turks, and British have governed there,
but not the Palestinians."
"The elimination by force of Israel is impossible and all attempts to do so are doomed in advance, as well as illegal."
Conrad Black, Canadian businessman, publisher, writer, historian
"Over
700,000 Palestinians were forcefully expelled from their homes, more
than 15,000 were massacred, and over 500 of their villages were
destroyed."
"To
uphold our commitment to social justice, decolonization and
reconciliation, it is imperative that we ensure students do not leave
the education system completely ignorant of the history of Palestine and
Israel. We cannot have yet another generation grow up believing it's
'too complicated' or 'too sensitive'."
Pro-Palestinian 'activist' group letter, British Columbia
Action Alert #30 Demand That the Nakba Be Added to the BC Curriculum-- Muslim Alert
"[The proposal in the letter sent to the NDP British Columbia government] is a distortion of 'what happened in 1948'."
"It
omits the fact that the [Arab] Palestinians launched the war in
defiance of the proposal by the international community [UN partition
plan]."
"That's
not in there and neither is the second part of the war, which was
launched by the Arab states when they invaded Israel in May 1948."
"It
doesn't explain why 700,000 Jews were uprooted from the Arab states in
which they had lived until 1948, under pressure by Arab societies and
Arab governments, creating a Jewish refugee problem. None of this is
explained or touched upon at all in that proposal they made."
"Students
in British Columbia learn about history throughout the K-12 curriculum
-- including references to international wars and global conflicts."
"At
the local level, school districts and teachers us their professional
judgement when choosing to incorporate current and historical conflicts
into their lesson planning that align with the required learning
standards of the curriculum."
British Columbia education ministry statement
Protesters hold an effigy of Canada’s Prime Minister
Justin Trudeau during a rally to call for a ceasefire, amid the ongoing
conflict between Israel and the Palestinian Islamist group Hamas in
Gaza, on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada March 9, 2024. (photo credit: REUTERS/Ismail Shakil)
Organizers
of an open letter demanding a new curriculum in British Columbia's
school system that would feature politicized content on the conflict
between Israel and the Palestinians include the Samidoun Palestinian
Prisoner Network which has its headquarters in Vancouver, and which is
known to have close associations with the Popular Front for the
Liberation of Palestine, widely acknowledged as a terrorist group,
listed on Canada's designated list of international terrorist
organizations.
Samidoun
has recognition from Germany -- the 20th century's infamous, most
lethal proponent of acidic antisemitism -- as a major proponent of
repulsive racist hatred toward Jews, and as such is not only deemed a
terrorist group, but is proscribed from operating in Germany, in accord
with its laws against Holocaust denial and antisemitism in a state
dedication to rejecting its shameful past in recognition of its
monumental debt to humanity.
In
Justin Trudeau's Canada, with the Liberal leader's eye fixed on a large
and growing voting bloc, unwilling to hazard alienating
Arab/Palestinian/Muslim votes, Samidoun with its well-known penchant for
demonizing Israel and Jews is nonchalantly permitted to operate. On
October 7, even while Hamas began committing its widespread atrocities
in southern Israel, Samidoun's statement glorified the ongoing massacre:
"The
resistance is rising throughout occupied Palestine, smashing the siege
on Gaza with a comprehensive offensive, confronting the occupier by
land, air and sea", completing its jubilant sentiment over sadistic savagery with images of terrorists clad in keffiyehs.
The
British Columbia education ministry responded to the letter
non-committally, leaving open an opportunity for committed antisemites
in its public school system to proceed with their own biased
interpretation, apart from, or filling in the regular school curriculum
by advising parents to contact their child's teacher or principal should
they wish to discuss what is being taught in the school their children
attend.
At the Annual General Meeting of the British Columbia Teachers’
Federation (BCTF), teacher delegates passed a historic
motion about Palestine. The motion asked the BCTF to push the Ministry
of Education to include the Nakba and the military occupation of Gaza
and the West Bank in the BC curriculum. Spring Magazine
These
'social activists' looking to improve on the reality of historical
events they view with the jaundiced eye of cherished victimhood, sent
their letter with its demands to Rachna Singh, British Columbia's
minister of Education and Child Care, insisting social studies curricula
in the province be overhauled to draw attention to the "Nakba" (catastrophe) that Palestinians mourn and Jews celebrate, as the formal rebirth of the State of Israel.
This
refers to the time when five Arab countries responded to the
declaration of statehood for Israel by amassing a collective military
assault on the nascent Jewish State. Historian Gil Troy's thought was
the implementation of a constructive lesson plan could alternately
examine support for partition and the two-state solution from
then-diplomat Lester B. Pearson, later Nobel Laureate, and Prime
Minister of Canada. A lesson plan that would provoke students "to think for themselves" not reliant on "partisan lies" as a service to young students.
Samidoun
was not alone in writing the letter with its appeal for justification
in 'adjusting' history. There was input by other interested
'pro-Palestinian' (the preferred term to 'anti-Israel, anti-Jew)
groups such as Teachers 4 Palestine BC, Palestinian Youth Movement
Vancouver, and Independent Jewish Voices, a fringe group promoting
Holocaust denial conspiracies which doesn't hesitate to participate in
events staged by antisemites and sympathizers of terrorism aimed at Jews
and Israel.
Israeli infantry making a full assault on Egyptian forces in the Negev area of Israel during the war of independence.Photo by Keystone/Getty Images
"By
not acknowledging that most Palestinian Arabs rejected the compromise
-- and encouraged terrorist attacks on their Palestinian Jewish
neighbours -- the petition, and implicitly the curriculum doesn't
explain how the war truly began."
"[The
letter demanding school curricula be altered, is an example of]
twistory, not history [framed to perpetuate a simplistic] misleading
[narrative with no educational value]."
"And
it, of course, ignores the invasion by outside Arab armies in May 1948,
when the Jews, who accepted the compromise, launched Israel, as per the
UN's vision."
"It
overlooks the United Nations' attempt at compromise -- in its 1947
Partition Plan, which recognized the historical legitimacy of Jewish
ties to the land. It also ignores the fact that Canada voted for the
partition and that a great Canadian leader, Lester B. Pearson, had a
leading role in drawing up the proposed compromise."
"The
letter takes a complicated conflict, which could be taught sensitively
and thoughtfully, with a nuance and respect for the truth, and reduces
it to a one-sided opportunity to erase the history of Israel, the
legitimacy of Zionism, the depth of Jewish ties to the land -- while
bashing Canada along the way."
Distinguished historian Gil Troy, McGill University academic
This represents a general opinion site for its author. It also offers a space for the author to record her experiences and perceptions,both personal and public. This is rendered obvious by the content contained in the blog, but the space is here inviting me to write. And so I do.