Trump's Personal Quest For American Dominance
"Let's be real about this; the rhetorical attacks on Canada have not actually resulted in a net good for the United States."
"[The
White House habit of] yelling at Canada [helped to install a] far
left-leaning internationalist [government] hostile to American
interests."
"All
of this started off as a joke, and I think President Trump is so
committed to the bit at this point that he couldn't get off the train
[repeated pledges to turn Canada into the '51st state']."
Conservative U.S. podcaster Ben Shapiro
"[Poilievre
would have been] Canuck DeSantis [Ron DeSantis, Republican governor of
Florida who challenged Trump for the 2024 Republican nomination]."
"Trump will [and has already] weirdly get on with Carney."
"Trump vibes with the smart, hyper-machievellaian center-left type."
Curt Mills, editor, American Conservative
 |
| Mark Carney with supporters at a victory party in Ottawa, 29 April 2025. Photograph: Dave Chan/AFP/Getty Images |
U.S.
President Donald Trump is smirking triumphantly. It has been his very
direct interference in Canadian affairs that succeeded in upsetting the
trajectory of the April 28 general election. A situation where
the Liberal Party of Canada succeeded in gathering a greater number of
votes, sufficient to form a minority government, than the Conservative
Party which had been surging in the polls before Mr. Trump introduced
the shock of his announced trade tariffs targeting first Canada and
Mexico and China, before he included much of the rest of the world.
The
Canadian public was well and truly sick of the Liberal government, its
never-ending ethical scandals, its impoverishment of the Canadian
economy, its massive annual deficits and a debt larger than anything any
previous government had ever attained. The federal government
estrangement from the Western provinces linked to its green agenda of
refusing to exploit the generosity of natural resources in the energy
field, has caused a rift between the provinces themselves, favouring the
east and damning the west.
Runaway
rising costs of food and lodging, a failing universal health system
overburdened by an unsustainable and indiscriminate surge in
immigration, refugee and migrant intake, along with other social
services strained to their limits, including insufficient and
prohibitively costly housing stocks, rising crime rates that a soft
judiciary intent on giving bail for the most serious criminal offenders
leading to a steadily rising crime rate. The twin problems of growing
homelessness among whom people in mental distress loom large, along with
an ever-widening circle of drug dependent, overdose-prone addicts.
President Trump, stay out of our election. The only people who will decide the future of Canada are Canadians at the ballot box.
Canada will always be proud, sovereign and independent and we will NEVER be the 51st state.
Factor
in ethnic/religious communities that no longer adapt to the Canadian
way of life, its social contracts, its value system, its laws and
regulations, and you have a restive population, resentful of a
government whose policies and idiosyncracies in social engineering and
race and gender politics have created deep divisions within society. All
of which soured the public on the Liberal government headed by Justin
Trudeau, the very embodiment of an entitled, sociopathic, deceitful,
manipulative and narcissistic personality.
His
government was in tatters; the antithesis of all that it represented
was seen in the Conservative government with its leader, Pierre
Poilievre prepared, given the Conservative-approving soaring polls, to
win the next election. And then along came Donald Trump. And along came
an international banker set to replace Justin Trudeau, boasting a record
of accomplishment as former Governor of the Bank of Canada and of Great
Britain. A man every bit as narcissistic as Trudeau, given to
stretching the truth to suit his agenda, a man for whom plagiarizing and
claiming as his own the intellectual work of others, slid by his
supporters.
On the campaign trail Mark Carney who was elevated into the role of Prime Minister by the simple (and unprincipled) expedient
of being voted in as leader of the Liberal Party in place of Justin
Trudeau, and who then went on to boast of his professional expertise and
successes in the world of finance, with no experience whatever in
politics, and no seat in Parliament, to promise that he, and only he
could lead Canada in its battle against an American president determined
to economically ruin Canada and annex it into American territory.
Canadians
in enough of a majority voted for the man who promised he would be
Donald Trump's worse nightmare. A man who charged his Conservative
competitor Pierre Poilievre of being just like Trump. When the truth is
that Trump saw Poilievre as an impediment to his plans of absorbing
Canada, and Carney as a useful tool in his extortion and coercion plans.
Immediately after the election, US. President Trump spoke of Mark
Carney as a "very nice gentleman" and their latest telephone conversation "couldn't have been nicer and I congratulated him".
 |
| On Monday, U.S. President Donald Trump weighed in on the federal
election, offering advice to Canadians about how they should vote. (Balce Ceneta/The Canadian Press) |
He plans, he stated, to meet with Carney "within the next week or less" in Washington, and expects to have a "great relationship" with Canada. "I actually think the Conservative hated me much more than the so-called 'Liberal'", Mr. Trump admitted. White House spokesperson Anna Kelly asserted to the Associated Press that the Canadian election "does not affect President Trump's plan to make Canada America's cherished 51st state". And his press secretary, Karoline Leavitt reinforced that message; that Trump's calls for Canada to become the 51st state were "Trump truthing, all the way".
The
Canadian election outcome was heavily weighed by the antagonism seen
from Trump against Canadian sovereignty and his disdain for the role of
any Canadian prime minister whom he preferred to call a 'governor'.
Trump made no secret of the fact that he planned to ruin the Canadian
economy, as additional pressure to have Canada accede to his plans of
being absorbed into the United States; his personal quest for American
dominance.
Labels: America's 51st State, Canadian General Election, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, Donald Trump, Election Interference, Liberal Leader Mark Carney
In the Spirit of Honesty, Integrity, Transparency
"[We
had a] constructive [discussion both agreeing to begin comprehensive
negotiations on a new economic and security relationship between Canada
and the United States] as sovereign nations [immediately following the
28 April federal election in Canada]."
"Look,
the president says lots of things, but the essence of the [shared
telephone] discussion and where we moved the conversation to was exactly
what I said."
"We
talked about lots of things, OK? And what's important is the
conclusions of the call, the results of the call, and those are exactly
the same on the American side and the Canadian side."
"And those were that it was very constructive."
"Who can stand up to President Trump, who can build Canada strong, who has the experience in order to do that?"
"That's the crucial choice that Canadians need to make."
Liberal leader, Mark Carney
 |
| U.S. President Donald Trump, left, and Canadian Prime Minister Mark
Carney had their first phone conversation on March 28. Sources tell
Radio-Canada that Trump raised the idea of Canada as the 51st state on
the call. (Evelyn Hockstein/Reuters, Blair Gable/Reuters) |
"I'm not their strategist, I'm not imagining wild conspiracies, but I can imagine that it serves them."
"Liberals
are [juggling[ between pretending that Mr. Carney has extinguished the
threat [of Trump annexing Canada] and regularly resurrecting that threat
because fear has been their main argument at the start of the Liberal
campaign."
Bloc Quebecois Leader Yves-Francois Blanchet
Mark
Carney, smug and self-confident that he will win Monday's general
election to become elected Prime Minister of Canada, is accustomed to
manipulating the truth to his advantage. He evades the truth, preferring
to replace it with his version of events that are likelier to portray
him as he feels he should be viewed; superior, entitled and exceptional.
In that way, as in so many others he is the mirror-image of the man he
intends to replace, former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
Mr.
Carney has already established a track record of unethical behaviour;
the most notable one to be brought to the attention of an electorate
prior to the ballot, is his having ethically invalidated his doctorate
by the expedient of casual plagiarism. More latterly, he denied having
had any hand in moving Brookfield Asset Management headquarters from
Canada to the United States, at a time when he was still its head. Nor
seeking out a tax haven for Brookfield to avoid paying taxes directly in
Canada.
Now
it has been revealed that in his March 28 telephone conversation with
President Trump, the threat of annexing Canada to the United States had
come up, even as Mr. Carney later claimed publicly that President Trump "respected Canada's sovereignty".
Radio-Canada had reported that Mr. Trump had indeed brought up the idea
of Canada as the 51st state during their exchange. Mr. Carney sought to
exploit his version of events to portray himself as a strong leader
whom the American President respected enough to avoid speaking of
annexing the country.
 |
| Liberal Party
Leader Mark Carney says his phone call with U.S. President Donald Trump
on Friday morning was very ‘cordial’ between two leaders of two
sovereign nations. Carney says Trump respected Canada’s sovereignty both
in his private and public comments on Friday. CBC News |
"To
be clear, as I've said to anyone who's raised this issue in private or
in public, including the president, it will never happen",
Mr. Carney said at an election stop in British Columbia; that under his
leadership the threat to annex Canada by economic force would never
come to pass. What Mr. Carney also failed to reveal about the
conversation with President Trump was his having alerted the American
president that as part of his electoral campaigning, he planned to use
the threats as fuel to inspire fear in Canadians to enhance his claims
that he was the right person to lead Canada.
Accordingly,
in a cooperative gesture, Trump's own read-out of the call with Carney
saw him dial back talk of Canada as the 51st state. And nor has he
spoken dismissively of Carney as the "governor" of Canada. He obviously
finds more in common with Carney's business/banker approach to
government than that of Justin Trudeau's commitment to diversity, equity
and inclusion. If nothing else, Trump reacts to blustery confidence and
he hasn't done his homework on Carney for whom DEI, a green agenda and a
commitment to quash Canada's natural resources in energy are a driving
force.
White
House press secretary Karoline Leavitt denied a change of stance had
occurred on the annexation of Canada; that President Trump still "believes that Canadians would benefit greatly from becoming the 51st state of the United States of America". During a signing ceremony at the Oval Office last week Mr. Trump said that Canada "would cease to exist as a country" if the U.S. stopped buying its goods and that Canada "as a state, it works great".
"He has these things in his mind. This is not news."
"He raises it all the time. But then the question is, what's going to be done with it? And does he understand where we stand?"
"More particularly, where do I stand? He is under no illusions."
Mark Carney, aspirant to the leadership of Canada
 |
| U.S.
President Donald Trump has warned that 25 per cent tariffs against
Canadian-made cars could go up. He also expressed his desire to make
Canada the 51st state after a period of relative quiet on his annexation
threats. CBC News |
The
latest and newest revelations of Mr. Carney's failure to respect the
truth and relay it to the public at a time when voters are entitled to
know exactly what it is they are voting for and for whom as a candidate
most likely to act in Canada's best interests during an economic
slowdown of recession proportions, during a time of provincial
alienation in response to the Liberal government's decision-making
impeding their decision making on energy extraction, when society in
general has been politically fractured, and the country's social
services and universal health care network is facing collapse, marks a
failure of leadership.
Instead,
during the campaign Carney has portrayed himself as a Canadian hero
during the economic downtown of the 1980s when as Governor of the Bank
of Canada, he lead Canada out of a recession; when in fact it was not he
but then-Finance Minister Jim Flaherty and the Canadian banking system
that saved Canada. During a recent press conference, the man who has
never been elected to public office, but who aspires to govern a nation,
when asked about the need for ethics and transparency laws in
government, responded that he would have no problems distinguishing
between rules and conduct:
"If there were specific proposals, obviously we would look at them."
"But
what's important is bringing that spirit of honesty, the highest
integrity, and my track record is consistent with that, but also that
commitment that goes with it to transparency."
Liberal leader Mark Carney
"I wasn't there [so cannot verify the heads-up Carney gave to Trump]."
"But
what's clear is that we will stand up for our sovereignty, we will
never be an American state, and we will focus on what we can control,
which is to reverse the disastrous Liberal economic policies that Mark
Carney advised Justin Trudeau to take."
Conservative leader, Pierre Poilievre
 |
| Conservative
Leader Pierre Poilievre, when asked about a Radio-Canada report saying
U.S. President Donald Trump mentioned ‘51st state’ during a call with
Prime Minister Mark Carney, said his Liberal rival will have to explain,
and he reiterated his call to defend Canada’s sovereignty and focus on
things Canada can control. Carney previously said Trump ‘respected
Canada’s sovereignty’ during the conversation. CBC News |
Labels: 28 April 2025, Canadian General Election, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre Can Rescue Canada, Liberal Leader Mark Carney, Recession Agenda, U.S. President Donald Trump
You Can Fool Some of the People Some of the Time
"It is a solemn duty to serve as prime minister at this time of great consequence."
"Canada's new government is focused on things that matter most to
Canadians — more higher-paying jobs, improving affordability and making
Canada more secure."
"Canada will be action-oriented to meet
the moment."
"We will relentlessly pursue this positive agenda because Canadians know
that negativity isn't strength. Negativity won't bring down
the price of groceries. Negativity won't win a trade war."
Liberal leader Mark Carney
 |
| Carney gestures after his new cabinet members were sworn in at Rideau Hall in Ottawa. (Justin Tang/Canadian Press) |
"Mark Carney thinks Canadians are stupid. He thinks a little bit of
cosmetic surgery will allow the Liberals to disguise who they are and
make people forget what they did for ten years in order to elect them to a
fourth term."
"It's the same Liberal gang and same Liberal agenda."
Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre
 |
| Prime Minister Mark Carney, front fourth from left, poses with members
of the newly sworn-in Liberal cabinet following a ceremony at Rideau
Hall in Ottawa on Friday. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press) |
After
too many years of Justin Trudeau as prime minister of Canada when he
was first enthusiastically welcomed in 2015 as a fresh new face that
would give Canada a fresh new perspective and prosperity going into the
future as well as harmony between provinces and the federal government
would finally arrive,given Trudeau's much-vaunted 'sunny ways',
Canadians fed up with his Liberal administration finally stated loud and
clear that with this man continuing at the helm of the Liberal party,
the next general election would commit the Liberals to last place,
hanging on to scant seats.
With
the proverbial writing on the wall, Justin Trudeau had few options but
to resign, although he did it on his terms, taking his time and
arranging a successor long in the sights of the party. Bearing in mind
that each and every Liberal Member of Parliament and certainly those
that made up Trudeau's bloated cabinet supported and advanced every
initiative that he took as prime minister, from embracing Critical Race
Theory, Diversity, Equity and Inclusion and LGBTQ-2+, along with
transgender rights for school-age children.
Above
all, his Cabinet was quick to agree with their prime minister's
environmental agenda that virtually shut down Canada's exploitation of
its energy natural resources. Pipelines to carry oil and LNG to points
within Canada itself, much less to tidewater ports along with badly
needed refinery capacity were cancelled by the Liberal government as a
goodwill environmental gesture, while the country imported energy from
foreign sources. Perhaps most visually and dysfunctionally evident has
been the eruption of public displays of robust celebration of the right
of Palestinians in Gaza to promote Palestinian terrorist groups as
'fighters' against Israeli oppression.
 |
| A vast sea of Communist and Palestinian flags covers Parliament Hill in
Ottawa, exposing the radical extremist agenda that challenges support
for Israel and democratic values. (Photo: X.) |
These
'fighters', as Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad demonstrated their
fighting skills by entering southern Israel in a coordinated rush of
thousands of operatives with orders to create deadly mayhem in as wide a
circle as possible, and some five thousand terrorists, complemented by
ordinary Palestinians wasted little time in proving their prowess at
mass rape, employing sadistic savagery to mutilate, rape and murder
Israeli girls and women. Entire families were wiped out in farming
communities, their homes torched while they sought shelter in their
'safe rooms'. The toll of 1,200 massacred, 250 taken hostage is
celebrated in the streets of Canadian cities by Palestinians and their
sympathizers as 'resistance' to 'occupation', calling for a global
Intifada and Final Solution.
 |
| Pro-Palestinian protesters at a rally on Parliament Hill Saturday/ Spencer Colby/The Canadian Press |
Canada's
immigration system gone awry, welcoming 'refugees' from a conflict they
initiated, along with illegal migrants, students on visas, temporary
workers, all straining universal social welfare, including the country's
medicare system and creating a dire shortage of housing capacity. The
infiltration of a religious/political cohort with no intention of
integrating into Canada's culture, its values, its judicial system has
resulted in chaos, rising crime rates and a near-dysfunctional society
incapable of stemming the tide of hostile relations between ethnic
groups as civilizational norms become charged with resentment and
hatred.
So
what does the Liberal cabinet look like under Mark Carney, former
banker, economist, self-promoter, short-tempered doctoral plagiarist and
narcissist look like? Amazingly like the Justin Trudeau Liberal
cabinet. And what does the 'new' Liberal cabinet agenda hold for Canada?
Ah well, more of the same, only somewhat shielded from close scrutiny
as the new Liberal leader makes his agenda-cautious bid during a general
election for an electoral mandate to govern with a majority, not the
vanishing minority threatened under a renewed Trudeau government.
Mark
Carney's experience in two prestigious government positions; as
Governor of the Bank of Canada, and later Governor of the Bank of
England, distinguished him as a high flyer, but his actual performance
in each of those positions was less than glowing, despite his current
boasts of his positions having been indispensable to good government and
even better economics in both countries. The revelation that he had
plagiarized other economists' work without attribution, to plump up his
doctoral thesis at Harvard revealed a man with rather loose personal
ethics.
Mark
Carney's dedication to left-wing environmental politics is not second
to Justin Trudeau's; the latter was an apprentice to the former. Wealth
and a strong GDP performance now eludes Canada; our earning powers have
been starkly diminished. And Mark Carney, while disavowing any intention
to commit Canada not to disturb its vast energy resources in favour of
'renewable energy' sources is playing sly games with Canadians' trust
through his utter lack of integrity. His flirtation with the truth has
been revealed, as for example when he denied his role in the decision by
Brookfield Asset Management to move its head office to the U.S.
As for his crowd-pleasing decision to lift the carbon tax for individuals (while leaving it intact for corporations),
consider this: his career of the last several years was one of
campaigning internationally for net zero emissions -- certainly
impacting Canada's oil and gas resources. The Net Zero Banking Alliance
he created, committing major international banks to net zero carbon
emissions has seen latterly, major banks dropping out. The bloom is off
that rose, but Mr. Carney's determination to carry on with his net-zero
future for Canada remains on tap. Meanwhile, he is busy purloining from
the Conservative campaign of Pierre Poilievre promises they initiate,
claiming them as his own.
Should
this man be elected to lead a renewed Liberal government -- with all
the accoutrements of the old, discredited Liberal government, including
the same tired old, but newly-fired up members of Cabinet, all of whom
did their enthusiastic utmost to sell Justin Trudeau's unpopular,
divisive and disturbing agenda from a 'post-national' Canada, to one
bursting at the seams with new Canadians for whom there are too scant
services and little intelligent scrutiny respecting their anticipated
capacity to integrate into Canadian culture, in the process destroying
all that is decent and civilized -- all the rejected positions taken by
the 'old' Liberal government, will flare into new life under the 'new'
Liberal government.
"It
takes only a cursory glance at his record to work out that Carney's
reputation is completely overblown. In reality, he has been
'over-promoted', and, in over eight years at the Bank of England, was at
best an indifferent governor and at worst a disappointing failure."
"He
created a mess and ... is the epitome of a remote, globalized,
technocratic elite. He is very good at self-promotion, at collecting
trophy jobs and of course negotiating fabulously generous salaries and
expenses for himself."
"He is just not very good at delivering."
Matthew Lynn, Daily Telegraph
 |
| Liberal leader Mark Carney, left, and Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre. POSTMEDIA FILE PHOTOS |
Labels: April 28, Canada Federal Election, Choices, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, Honesty, Integrity, Liberal Leader Mark Carney, Love of Canada
Charming Beijing Captivates Liberal Loyalty
"[These
comments] deeply offended, [demonstrating a] terrible lapse in
judgement [however, the episode could serve as a] teachable moment."
"This
is a person of integrity who served his community as a senior police
officer for ... more than a quarter of [a] century. He's made a terrible
lapse in judgement."
"He's
made his apology. He's made it to the public, he's made it to the
individual concerned, he's made it directly to me, and he's going to
continue with his candidacy."
"He has my confidence."
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney
"[The response by Mr. Carney is indeed a] teachable moment."
"It teaches us that Mark Carney will never stand up for Canada."
"If
Mark Carney won't stand up for a Canadian against this foreign hostile
regime now, how could we ever expect him to stand up for Canada after
the election?"
Conservative Party Leader Pierre Poilievre
"He
is a police officer, and he ought to know that when the CCP [Chinese
Communist Party] went out and put a bounty on anybody, including
Canadians, that cannot be acceptable."
"That is intimidation at its worst."
NDP MP Jenny Kwan
"What
we saw was the news of the bounty was sort of re-upped, but we're just
watching the open space for anything related to that."
"That alone, I think, is a form of coercion."
"Spreading, again, the information about the bounty is precisely how malign foreign states seek to silence, harass and coerce."
Rapid Response Mechanism head Larisa Galadza, Global Affairs Canada
 |
|
Paul Chiang is seeking
re-election in Markham-Unionville, a riding he took from the
Conservatives in 2021 by a margin of fewer than 2,500 votes. Justin Tang The Canadian Press file photo
|
"If you can take him to the Chinese Consulate General in Toronto, you can get the million-dollar reward",
advised Liberal electoral candidate Paul Chiang to an news conference
comprised of Chinese-language media, in reference to Conservative
candidate Joe Tay who had been charged under the Hong Kong national
security law as a threat to Beijing for his Canada-based YouTube channel
critical of the Beijing-dominated CCP government.
When
the comment hit headlines in the legacy media in Canada, calls for the
Liberal party to disown Mr. Chiang and remove him as a Liberal candidate
for the April 28 federal election expressed the disgust of most
Canadians. Derisory statements by opposing political party candidates
are not uncommon during election campaigns, but seldom do they cross the
line into currying to foreign interference in Canada's affairs and
certainly never to the extent that one candidate incites to violence
against another.
Pressure
came fast and furious even within the Liberal party for Mr. Chaing to
be removed as a candidate in view of his comments last week. The bounty
in question, in Hong Kong dollars $1 million, transcribes to $183,000
in Canadian currency. Any taker could be assured of earning themselves a
reward for luring the Conservative candidate to appear at the Chinese
Consulate General in Toronto where he would be spirited to China and
imprisoned as a traitor to Beijing -- but certainly not to China.
Mr.
Chaing informed the Chinese-language media that given Mr. Tay's
position on China and Beijing's response, should Mr. Tay be elected to
Parliament, the Hong King criminal charge would be a cause of "great controversy", according to the Ming Pao newspaper.
And no doubt it would, since the Liberal Party goes out of its way to
pacify Beijing, and continues to build on its relationship through
trade, despite the assaults on Canadian sovereignty where Canadians have
been falsely imprisoned, Canadians have received the death penalty in
China, and Chinese interference in Canadian affairs is deeply troubling.
 |
| Liberal Leader Mark Carney says Paul Chiang will remain a candidate
under his banner, despite calls to drop the Markham-Unionville incumbent
for suggesting people turn in a Conservative candidate to the Chinese
consulate and collect a bounty. CBC News |
Even
so, even when Canadian Intelligence has warned government on many
occasions through updated reports that China is among those countries --
foremost among those countries -- that have used their expatriate
Chinese-Canadian community originally from Mainland China to act as
agents for Beijing, as well as instructing all expats that it is their
ancestral patriotic duty to infiltrate and capture whatever advances in
technology, science, medicine, and military news helpful to be conveyed
to China's possession.
Mr. Chiang himself saw fit to apologize soon after his comments were publicized:
"The
comments I made were deplorable and a complete lapse of judgement on
the seriousness of the matter. I sincerely apologize and deeply regret
my comments."
"I
will always continue to stand shoulder to shoulder with the people of
Hong Kong in their fight to safeguard their human rights and freedoms."
And
while unelected PM-incumbent Mark Carney is satisfied to let the matter
lie there and continue to approve Mr. Chiang as a Liberal candidate,
the man himself took the initiative to resign from the Liberal
candidacy. Whether his apology is sincere is debatable. He still took
the right course in apologizing and taking himself out of the election.
There is no debate that Mr. Carney, on the other hand, has often engaged
in dishonourable conduct. He has bent the truth to suit his fabricated
explanations.
And
on this occasion he has spectacularly failed to act with conscience and
integrity. Canadians should hold him to account for this, yet another
lapse in judgement on his part. On the other hand, government officials
tasked with identifying and responding to foreign threats during the
election period acknowledge they are monitoring the situation closely.
Moreover, the RCMP has opened an investigation in the matter. While the
man aspiring to be elected Prime Minister of Canada succumbed to his own
lack of moral integrity.
Mr.
Tay has been left uneasy and concerned over his safety, given the
obvious nature of the threats against him posed by a foreign government
whose record on human rights is abysmal. He has stated that the
situation left him fearing for his safety. Spurring him to get in touch
with the RCMP for his personal protection, and demanding that Carney
fire Chiang. A demand that thirteen pro-democracy groups in Canada
linked to Hong Kong produced a statement urging the Liberal Party to "send a clear message" in removing Chiang's candidacy, making it clear they cannot accept his "insincere apology".
"I want to be clear: no apology is sufficient."
"Threats like these are the tradecraft of the Chinese Communist Party to interfere in Canada."
"And
they are not just aimed at me. They are intended to send a chilling
signal to the entire community in order to force compliance to Beijing's
political goals."
Conservative federal election candidate Joe Tay
"[Foreign interference, including instances of transnational repression,
continue to be a] pervasive threat in Canada [and the federal police
takes all reports and allegations seriously]."
"The RCMP is looking into the matter, however no specific details can be
provided at this time.""To ensure the integrity of
our investigations, the RCMP typically does not disclose information
relating to investigations unless criminal charges are laid, rendering
it a matter of public record."
RCMP spokesperson Kristine Kelly
 |
| Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, speaking in New Brunswick, says
Liberal Leader Mark Carney’s decision to stand by candidate Paul Chiang,
who called for people to turn in Conservative candidate Joe Tay for a
Chinese bounty, ‘teaches us that Mark Carney will never stand up for
Canada.’ Poilievre added that he spoke to Tay and he is ‘very, very
rattled.’ CBC |
"It is a teachable moment. It teaches us that Mark Carney will never
stand up for Canada."
"The
Chinese government literally wants to kill Joe Tay because he’s a
political dissident. And this candidate said that that should happen."
"I have never in my life seen a prime minister
unwilling to protect a Canadian citizen against a foreign government
that wants to take his life through a bounty."
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre
Labels: Canadian General Election, Chinese Communist Party, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, Foreign Interference, Liberal Leader Mark Carney
One of Those Who Considers Himself the Most Intelligent Mind in the Room
"I believe you are mischaracterizing this work. As an academic of nearly 40 years, I see no evidence of plagiarism in the thesis you cited nor any unusual academic practices."
"Mark's thesis was evaluated and approved by a faculty committee that saw his work for what it is; an impressive and thoroughly researched analysis that set him apart from his peers."
Margaret Meyer, Official Fellow of Economics, Nuffield College, Oxford University
"Oxford's guidelines are not atypical from other universities."
"When you have something lifted verbatim from a source, in there without quotation marks or citation ... that constitutes plagiarism."
Oxford graduate professor
"He's just directly repeating without quotations. That's what we call plagiarism."
"[Some of Liberal Leader Mark Carney's thesis questions might be considered by some as more of a] grey area, [but it would still constitute plagiarism according to Oxford standards."
"It seems like it's [examples of plagiarism] all over the dissertation."
Geoffrey Sigalet, assistant professor, member UBC president's advisory committee on student discipline
Perhaps it would be more accurate to say that elite economist and now leader of the Liberal Party of Canada, Mark Carney, who has taken on the as-yet-unelected mantle of Canadian Prime Minister's 1995 doctoral thesis in economics from Oxford University, titled 'The Dynamic Advantage of Competition' is fairly well shot through with examples of plagiarism, an absolute sin in academic circles, as it is in journalism and other recorded-word disciplines. A total corruption of what is felt to be authentic, original observations based on study and analysis.
According to the learned judgement of three university academics there are ten distinct instances of apparent plagiarism in that doctoral thesis. Full quotes, paraphrases, or slightly modified quotes from four different writers previously published were used by this aspiring economist completely lacking acknowledgement or proper attribution. In the investigation leading to an expose published just recently, Oxford University administrators failed to respond to a request for comment.
His election adversary, Pierre Poilievre, leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, did respond by commenting on X:
Mark Carney loves to brag about his experience. Here it is:
- - Plagiarism
- - Tax evasion
- - Creative accounting
-
- Abusing tenants
- - Union busting
- - Moving his headquarters out of Canada to the U.S.
- - Denying insurance claims to coal miners dying of black lung
- - Taking massive loans from Chinese state-owned banks
- - Advisor to Justin Trudeau on the economy
Examples abound of Mr. Carney's laissez-faire attitude toward straightforward truth where he has been caught out on a number of occasions dissembling and playing with verifiable facts in an effort to shield himself from the responsibility incumbent on one who expects to be believed by a wide segment of the population when he declares himself fit and prepared to lead a nation. So perhaps it isn't quite surprising that his lax demeanor reflecting a propensity to lift other peoples' ideas and present them as his own has become habitual with the man.
There is the direct example of his lifting and adopting ideas and promises made by the Leader of the Official Opposition in Parliament during the current federal election campaign. Barely changing the wording of campaign pledges originating with Pierre Poilievre, to present them as his very own inspirations to better the lives of Canadians. Making other statements to appeal to the electorate that clearly belie his oft-stated beliefs and priorities which clash directly with those statements geared to impress voters in a positive manner.
In Mr. Carney's thesis he refers extensively to a 1990 book by Michael Porter, The Competitive Advantage of Nations, where he duplicated parts of Porter's work, presenting sentences with minor tweaks, as his very own brainchilds. Writing in his thesis virtually exactly what he had taken out of Porter's book, adding "an" to a sentence and "even", without quotation marks to alert the reader, without the addition of a footnote to reference someone else's work being quoted.
All perfectly acceptable, according to his thesis supervisor at Oxford who stated that "it is typical that overlapping language appears" when sources are "frequently referenced in an academic text. For example, over the course of this more than 300-page thesis, the Michael Porter book ... is cited dozens of times. Within his thesis, Mark acknowledged, cited, scrutinized and expanded on this piece", she elaborated, noting that his PHD thesis is "twice as long" as her own. Statements that should raise some eyebrows.
In some instances Mr. Carney duplicates another author's sentences using minor alterations, replacing "for example", with "e.g.", or changing one or a few words, for "be" to "become", or "likelihood" to "probability". Proper citation was not added to indicate he had lifted an author's words, nor were quotation marks added. Shifty practices which anyone who considers themselves as highly intelligent as Carney does, would acknowledge them to be.
 |
Canada is due to go to the polls on April 28 GETTY |
"[Plagiarism is regarded by Oxford University] as a serious matter."
"Cases will be investigated and penalties may range from deduction of marks to expulsion from the University, depending on the seriousness of the occurrence."
"[Oxford University defines plagiarism as [p]resenting work or ideas from another source as your own ... by incorporating it into your work without full acknowledgement."
Oxford University Website
 |
| On its website, Oxford University says it regards plagiarism “as a serious matter.” Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images |
Labels: 1995 Oxford Doctorate, Canadian Federal Election, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, Liberal Leader Mark Carney, Plagiarism