Beijing Bridling at Interference in Its 'Internal Affairs'
"[In
all likelihood, China viewed Russia's invasion of Ukraine failing to
gain its objective swiftly as] you don't achieve quick decisive
victories with underwhelming force."
"Our
sense is that it probably affects less the question of whether the
Chinese leadership might choose some years down the road to use force to
control Taiwan, but how and when they would do it."
"[The risks] become higher, it seems to us, the further into this decade that you get."
"I suspect the lesson that the Chinese leadership
and military are drawing is that you’ve got to amass overwhelming force
if you’re going to contemplate that in the future."
"[China
also has likely learned that it has to] control the information space
[and] do everything you can to shore up your economy against the
potential for sanctions."
William Burns, director, U.S. Central Intelligence Agency
President Tsai Ing-wen visits army reservists on exercises. The
undertrained force has to be reformed to provide resilience against an
attack by China Ann Wang/Reuters
"[It
would] severely undermine China's sovereignty and territorial
integrity, gravely impact the foundation of China-U.S. relations and
send a seriously wrong signal to Taiwan independence forces [should the
United States continue to interfere in China's internal politics]."
Zhao Lijiant, spokesperson, Chinese Foreign Ministry
"[Beijing still prefers] peaceful reunification."
"[The US supports] independence [forces in Taiwan, where
president Tsai Ing-wen has asserted the island’s separate identity]."
"No
conflict and no war is the biggest consensus between China and the
United States. [But the United States is] hollowing out and
blurring [its stated policy of recognizing only Beijing]."
"Only
by adhering strictly to the one-China policy, only by joining hands to
constrain and oppose Taiwan independence, can we have a peaceful
reunification."
Qin Gang, China’s ambassador to the United States
Taiwanese soldiers hold military drills in Taipei
Credit: Ann Wang/Reuters
China
has been aggressively harassing Taipei, entering its air space as a
warning that it is growing impatient with the island state's adamant
refusal to rejoin the mainland. Beijing's ongoing efforts to isolate
Taiwan on the world stage, refusing it recognition as a sovereign state,
in the United Nations and in international diplomatic relations is just
the initial step in its campaign to return Taiwan to China's tender
care. Taiwan is alert to the imminence of an invasion.
The
tension between mainland China and its breakaway republic is steadily
increasing, thanks to China's more belligerent overtures. Now that
Beijing has consolidated its premature hold over Hong Kong, Taiwan is
next on its agenda. Xi Jinping makes no secret about his determination
to bring Taiwan back into the fold, from its status as a defiant,
breakaway republic. He did not hesitate to revoke Hong Kong's
semi-autonomous status, despite a signed agreement that status would be
in place for a fifty year period.
And
nor will he allow world opinion and the censure along with an increased
threat not only of economic sanctions imposed by the United States
should Beijing move precipitously to regain what it feels it has
unjustly lost, but the prospect of a wider conflict should the United
States engage in supporting Taiwan with U.S. military intervention, as
U.S. President Joe Biden recently asserted.
President Joe Biden, during a recent trip to Japan, told a reporter he
was willing to use force to defend Taiwan Eugene Hoshiko/Pool/EPA-EFE
For
Beijing and its president, the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the goal
somewhat similar in nature to Beijing's own, represents a test case
whose prosecution and outcome presents as a lesson in what not to do for
a successful and timely outcome in its plans for Taiwan. Moscow's
'strategic failure' is a lesson gained for Beijing, a primary observer
directly related to its own, similar plans.
House
Speaker Nancy Pelosi - about as senior an American diplomatic presence
as any next to the president himself -- plans to visit Taiwan in the
coming month, despite that the U.S. military has cautioned her against
such plans. Her original plan to visit Taipei in April was postponed
when she tested positive for COVID-19. With news of her renewed
intention to visit the region, stopping at Japan and Vietnam as well as
Taiwan, Beijing has warned of 'repercussions'.
"We
are indeed in the midst of very large-scale and thorough discussions
both among ourselves and with the Americans right now about the things
we need to do."
"We
are exploring a range of radically different ideas for making our
country resilient, to build the features we need in wartime."
"Our
goal is to be ready between 2025 and 2027 [for China's invasion and
attempted occupation of Taiwan to secure 'reunification']."
Senior (unnamed) Taiwanese official
Taipei wants to retain military capabilities, such as its F-5 fighter
jets, to counter Chinese incursions Ritchie B Tongo/EPA-EFE
"It
is true that the U.S.-China relationship is in a precarious and
possibly dangerous place [given ongoing friction in bilateral ties and
uncertainty related to China's domestic politics]."
\"I think that the United States should articulate a clear and consistent policy toward Taiwan and cross-strait issues."
"We have had a significant amount of confusion in U.S. policy that has led China to question what our intentions are."
Bonnie Glaser, director, Asia Programme, German Marshall Fund
Russians: 'You Will See Our Faces ... Not Our Backs'
Russians: 'You Will See Our Faces ... Not Our Backs'
"You have been told that this flame will bring liberation to Ukraine's people. But the Ukrainian people are free."
"Donetsk,
which I have visited dozens of times? Where I looked in people's faces,
in their eyes? Artyoma Street, where I strolled with friends? The
Donbas Arena, where I rooted for our boys together with Ukrainian lads
at the European Championships? Shcehrbakov Park, where I drank with
friends when our boys lost?"
"Luhansk, where the mother of my best friend is buried? Where his father also rests?"
"Many
of you have visited Ukraine. Many of you have relatives here. Some
might have studied at Ukrainian universities and befriended Ukrainians.
You know our character; you know our people, and you know our
principles. You know what we value."
"So stop and listen to yourselves, to the voice of reason, to the voice of common sense."
"The
Ukrainian people want peace, as does their government. We know for sure
that we don't need the war. Not a Cold War, not a hot war. Not a hybrid
one. But if these forces attack us, if they try to take our country
away from us, our freedom, our lives, the lives of our children, we will
defend ourselves.Not attack, but defend ourselves."
"And when you attack, you will see our faces. Not our backs, our faces."
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, an appeal to Russia
The mass exodus of refugees from Ukraine to the eastern edge
of the European Union showed no signs of stopping Monday as civilians
flee Russia’s burgeoning war, with the United Nations estimating that
more than half a million people have already escaped. Here, people wait
in freezing conditions to board a bus bound for a refugee centre in
Przemyśl, Poland, on Monday. (Bryan Woolston/Reuters)
Ukrainians
are fleeing their country. In staggering numbers, on their way to
becoming a full-scale refugee crisis in Europe not seen since the Second
World War. A crisis that has been the result of Vladimir Putin's
decision to mount a full-scale invasion on his neighbour, knowing full
well that imposing the threat and the reality of countless deaths and
destruction will inevitably cause hundreds of thousands of people to
seek refuge elsewhere than where he has directed his military to strike.
And
since he has directed his military to strike wholesale throughout the
length and breadth of Ukraine, the response has been disastrous; refugee
numbers are exploding from day to day. Several days earlier an
estimated 368,000 Ukrainians fled to the borders of their European
neighbours; Poland, Hungary, Moldova, Slovakia and Romania, with
thousands more desperately attempting to forge their way through clogged
borders.
People,
frightened and vulnerable, waiting for hours in the cold, in cars, or
on foot; with them the bare few belongings they could manage to assemble
in their panic to escape. A 14-kilometre-long backlog was assembled at
the crossing into Poland two days ago. Some people had been waiting for
40 hours in -18C night-time temperatures.
Ukrainian refugees are seen at the temporary refugee centre
in a local primary school at Tiszabecs, eastern Hungary on Monday.
(Attila Kisbenedek/AFP/Getty Images)
In
2015 over a million refugees flooded Europe's borders, coming from
Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan, triggering a continent-wide crisis with
some countries willing to accept some refugees and others adamant that
they would not. And those that would not take in Muslim refugees fleeing
the countries of their birth, beset by horrendous violence from
Islamist forces and their very own leaders, are now opening their
borders wide to Ukrainian refugees.
Countries
such as Slovakia, Hungary and Poland, where their borders had been
hardened on that earlier 2015 occasion, assailed by waves of refugees
from the Middle East and North Africa are preparing to welcome Ukrainian
refugees into their fold. German Interior Minister Nancy Faeser stated
Germany was ready to offer Poland and other Eastern European countries
support in the handling of the sudden Ukrainian refugee surge.
Up
to five million of Ukraine's total 44 million population could become
refugees, warns the United Nations, should Russia's attacks on Ukraine
continue. For the most part it is women, children and the elderly who
mass at the borders, since Ukrainian men have been barred from leaving,
in light of President Zelensky having called on Ukrainian males to take
up arms in defence of their country.
To
complicate matter still further, a data-wiping software has hit a
Ukrainian border control station processing people trying to enter
Romania, according to a cybersecurity expert. "It's massively hitting the border control. They are processing people with pen and pencil."
Poland
is setting up reception centres along the contiguous 480-kilometre
border with Ukraine, offering food, medical care and needed social
welfare resources. Thousands of soldiers from the U.S. Army 82nd
Airborne Division have been deployed to assist. In 15 hours on Saturday
alone, 45,200 Ukrainian refugees crossed into Poland.
Refugees fill a warehouse in Poland after escaping Ukraine.
"I ask you to lay down your arms and surrender to avoid bloodshed and unnecessary deaths."
"Otherwise , you will be bombed."
"Russian warship."
"Go f--- yourself."
Audio has emerged of a dramatic standoff between Russian forces
attempting to capture Snake Island off the coast of Ukraine and those
charged with defending it.
Positioned on a desolate rocky island, a small team of Ukrainian border guards received a message warning them of immediate peril should they refuse to surrender the outpost. The Ukrainian response was immediate and visceral; they had no intention whatever of attempting to preserve their lives at the cost of surrendering to a Russian military vessel, part of the invasion pounding targets across Ukraine with bombs and missiles.
The predictable result of their defiance against all odds, with full knowledge that instead of surrendering their duty to defend their country, they were surrendering their lives willingly, the Russians opened fire with a series of bombs. And before long all thirteen border guards were dead. The stand on the Black Sea lifted Ukrainian morale and pride in themselves, refusing to bow to Russian tyranny.
The thirteen Russian border guards had stood down the grim orders to betray their country's trust in its servicemen and in so doing became heroes that championed their nation's honour and aspirations to remain free and at liberty to make decisions leading it toward increasing democracy and away from the stultifying, degradation of remaining a vassal state of the Russian Federation.
Snake Island, in the Black Sea. Image credit: Ukraine MoD
They were being awarded with the highest honour their country could bestow on men who exhibited extraordinary courage in the face of an enemy onslaught, the 'Hero of Ukraine' titled honorific award. The Ukrainian news outlet Ukrayinska Pravda posted on their website a copy of the recording of the dramatically terse and sinister conversation between the Ukrainian border agents and the Russian vessel.
Another recording was posted on TikTok, illustrating a border guard in helmet and balaclava on the atoll Zmiinyi Island (Snake Island) cursing under fire. He was a 23-year-old,from Odessa, a Ukrainian port city on the Black Sea. The border guards had attempted to secure the island on Thursday for hours, before they were killed.
The 42-acre, sparsely populated island sits on the edge of Ukraine's territorial waters, a strategic area within the Black Sea that connects a shipping corridor to the cities of Odessa, Mykolaiv and Kherson, Ukraine.
"Peace
on our continent has been shattered. Russia is using force to try to
rewrite history, and deny Ukraine its free and independent path."
"This
is a deliberate, cold-blooded and long-planned invasion. Russia's
unjustified, unprovoked attack on Ukraine is putting countless innocent
lives at risk with air and missile attacks."
NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg
Missiles pounded Kyiv on Friday, Feb. 25, 2022, as Russian
forces advance to the outskirts of the Ukrainian capital — a day after
Russian President Vladimir Putin launched an invasion of Ukraine that
has shocked the world. Here, Natali Sevriukova is seen next to her home
in Kyiv after a rocket attack. (Emilio Morenatti/The Associated Press)
NATO
plans to create combat units in Romania and Bulgaria, possibly Hungary
and Slovakia as well, to reflect those already set up several years
earlier in Poland and the Baltic states, as a deterrent to potential
Russian aggression in Vladimir Putin's pathological delusion that he
will go down in history with a legacy project fulfilled; the
reincarnation of the Soviet Union by re-creating the forcible union that
most of its neighbours dread.
No
NATO troops were to be sent to Ukraine to aid its resistance to the
Russian invasion. Ukraine is on its own. Its delicate state of ongoing
oppression by Russia was what led NATO to keep Ukraine at arm's length,
even though other former USSR satrapies have been accepted into the
Alliance. Foreseeing just such an event occurring at some future date --
albeit not quite in the violent form currently seen -- led NATO to err
on the side of caution.
"As
recently as 2016, an operation on this scale would have required every
battalion tactical group in Russia's ground forces; with more contract
personnel, and thus more BTGs, Moscow can now undertake such a move
while still retaining substantial forces elsewhere in Russia."
IISS Military Balance 2022 global military capacity survey
Ukraine,
the second-largest country in Europe, is hugely outmatched against the
largest geographic country in the world, Russia, despite materiel
support that NATO countries have provided to the Ukraine military to
help beef up its military arsenal. In 2020, military spending in Ukraine
came in at about $6 billion, roughly a tenth of the figure for Russian
military expenditures for the same year; $62 billion.
Russia
has had quite a bit of practise in nipping away bits and pieces of the
geography of former Soviet member-countries. As it did in Georgia, and
that former Soviet satellite was left to defend itself and still lost
two of its territories to Russia. Russian warplanes have had ample
practise, not just the war games of recent vintage with Belarus, but
real-time conflict flying aerial missions over Syria where it bombed
civilian enclaves, along with hospitals.
Its
practise run in 2014 with ethnic Russian rebels culminating for the
time being with the seizing of the Crimean peninsula and portions of
eastern Ukraine in the Donbas gave it ample practise for a long-range
plan for total control and absorption of Ukraine in its bid for imperial
influence over the former Soviet Union states. Ukraine has been viewed
by President Putin as the jewel in its imperial crown, first to be
wholly re-absorbed, leaving other former states in fear.
After
the dissolution of the Soviet Union, when Russia was left a crumbling
vestige of its former self, the ascension of Vladimir Putin to the
presidency several decades ago saw Russia's vast reserves of gas and oil
in huge demand throughout Europe. That source of income built Russia a
formidable treasury, quite a bit of it used for rebuilding its military.
Enabling
him at this juncture to deploy over 100,000 troops to the border with
Ukraine and 30,000 in Belarus, a show of purpose for that military
investment in the past 35 years. Reclaiming Abkhazia and South Ossetia
were mere trifles to practise on; the absorption of Ukraine is more to
the point for Mr. Putin's reemerging Greater Russia ambitions.
12
Russian battalion tactical groups were put into action around northeast
Ukraine in 2015 during the war that wasn't quite a war, but as U.S.
President named it, a 'minor incident'. Not, however, so minor to
Ukraine which lost Crimea in that bitter encounter. Now, well over 100
battalion tactical groups have been deployed to make for this full-scale
invasion from Russia and Belarus.
Ukraine
has 290,000 military personnel, to Russia's 900,000, and Russia can
call up another two million reservists, as compared to Ukraine's
900,000. The Russian army has over 12,000 tanks, with Ukraine in
possession of less than 3,000. A similar imbalance exists in the numbers
of armoured vehicles and artillery. Ukraine with its 34 attack
helicopters and 98 jets is up against Russia's 500 attack helicopters
and 1,500 fighter jets.
Ukrainian President Vlodomir Zelensky insists he's not leaving Kyiv as Russian forces close in on the Ukrainian capital.
"[The
only way that Ukraine can end the crisis would be to surrender
ambitions to join NATO, declaring neutrality], demilitarize, [and give
up any territorial claim to Crimea]."
"We
expect, and I want to underline this, that all the difficult questions
will be solved during negotiations [between Kyiv and the separatist
leadership]."
Russian President Vladimir Putin
"We are committed to the peaceful and diplomatic path. We will follow it and only it."
"But we are on our own and, we are not afraid of anything and anybody."
"We owe nothing to no one, and we will give nothing to no one."
Ukrainian President Volodomyr Zelensky
Ukrainian
President Volodymyr Zelensky thanked Western nations for sanctions against Russia and warned that the future of European
security is being decided 'now, here, in Ukraine.
"If
Russia goes further with its invasion we stand prepared to go further
with sanctions. Russia will pay an even steeper price if it continues
its aggression."
Who
in the Lord's name does Putin think gives him the right to declare new
so-called countries on territory that belongs to his neighbours? This is
a flagrant violation of international law. [He is] carving out a chunk
of Ukraine."
"I
have authorized additional movements of U.S. forces and equipment,
already stationed in Europe, to strengthen our Baltic allies, Estonia,
Latvia and Lithuania."
"There is still time to avert the worst case scenario that will bring untold suffering to millions of people."
U.S. President Joe Biden
Ukrainian service members take part in tactical drills at a
training ground in an unknown location in Ukraine, in this handout
picture released Feb. 22, 2022. (Press service of the Ukrainian Armed Forces General Staff/Handout via Reuters)
How
much 'further with its invasion' must Moscow go to enable Washington to
identify geographical theft that goes somewhat beyond the 'minor
incident' that Mr. Biden mused about several weeks ago, leaving the
impression that NATO and the U.S. could somehow overlook something as
'minor' as, say a repeat of the 2014 invasion and annexation of Crimea?
The U.S. is a large country geographically, though not as large as
Russia.
What
would be the NATO and U.S. response if Russia looked with avarice at a
territory it once owned and sold to the United States for a pittance?
What would happen in response, as an example of a 'minor incident', if
Russia decided to invade Alaska reclaiming it as a territorial
imperative, that it should never have been released from Russian
ownership. It is, after all, much closer geographically to Russia than
it is to the United States....
Alaskans
would be threatened by the 'occupation' and the governance of a country
for whom violence is of little account in claiming what it insists is
its by historical account, a heritage property beyond dispute... The
social, civil upheaval with the resulting dispersal of civilian
populations would be enormous and tragic; reflecting what Ukrainian
citizens living in the occupied and now virtually annexed Donbas region
of Donetsk and Luhansk face.
Ukrainians attend a rally Wednesday to protest after Moscow's decision
to formally recognize two Russian-backed regions of Eastern Ukraine as
independent. (Carlos Barria/Reuters)
Anger
and determination to oppose Russia, on the part of those territories'
civilian populations will have them bearing arms and fighting for their
right to remain under Ukraine governance for they are Ukrainian and it
is their country and their children's futures they fight for. Using the
pretext of 'backing' the territorial claims of ethnic Russian
separatists is a transparent ploy to invite Ukraine to order its
military to greater action in defending Ukraine territory.
Giving
Vladimir Putin the final reason he agitates toward to ignite a wider
conflict. Mr. Biden's words of assurance to Latvia, Estonia, and
Lithuania, along with Poland and others, will ring empty when viewed
through the lens of European and NATO inaction in supporting Ukraine. It
is the entire Donbas region that will find its way into the Russian
Federation, and a little more gradually, more of Ukraine, as it defends
itself against a vastly superior military machine.
Of course, Mr. Putin himself expanded the message of 'diplomatic action' when he stated it to be "impossible to predict" just how far he planned to probe his military into Ukraine; his troops would enter and it would "depend on the specific situation on the ground".
As though to say that if Ukraine is unreasonable and decides to defend
itself irrespective of the losses -- of human life and territory -- then
poor, abused Russia will have little choice but to bulldoze through all
of Ukraine....
Police officers and members of the Ukrainian National Guard are seen outside the Russian Embassy in Kyiv on Wednesday. (Valentyn Ogirenko/Reuters)
"I deem it necessary to make a decision that should have been made a long time ago -- to immediately recognize the independence and sovereignty of the Donetsk People's Republic and the Luhansk People's Republic."
"If Ukraine was to join NATO it would serve as a direct threat to the security of Russia."
"[Russia and Ukraine are] parts of what is essentially the same historical and spiritual space; [their] spiritual unity [is under attack]."
"[What is happening to Ukraine today, is a] forced change of identity. And the most despicable thing is that the Russians in Ukraine are being forced not only to deny their roots, generations of their ancestors but also to believe that Russia is their enemy."
"So you [Ukraine] want de-communization? That suits us.
But let's not stop half way. We are prepared to show you what real
de-communization looks like."
"[Ukraine is not a real country, but one] created [by Russia in the 1920s] on ancient Russian lands".
Russian President Vladimir V. Putin
Vladimir Putin (l) at a meeting of Russia's national security chiefs on Monday (Photo: kremlin.ru)
The Russian commander of all that is Russia convened a meeting on Monday of his lieutenants in a special session of the Russian security council, meeting in St.Catherine's Hall in the Kremlin, resplendent in gleaming marble. An august setting for a theatre of impending conflict. A special convening, one where the musical accompaniment heard in the subconscious of all those present, was a slow rumble of the drums of war.
It was too splendid a theatre, too seriously onerous a decision not to share with all of Russia to view at a remove the seriousness with which their president views the impending danger their nation faces under the sinister denial of a neighbour unwilling to consider the Kremlin's offers of reinstatement of Ukraine in the bosom of Russia's fond historical memories.
Where an ingrate nation determined to rule itself as a sovereign right, makes a mockery of its own historical, heritage alignment with Russia. An insult not to be borne without a suitable response.
President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine speaking at the Munich Security Conference on Saturday.Credit...Pool photo by Ronald Wittek
What the meeting revealed to the enquiring eyes focused on the unfolding drama of top-echelon investigators and intelligence lieutenants was their striking reluctance to recommend war, outweighed by their fearful inhibitions over displeasing their interlocutor, he who cannot be denied. Moscow's foreign intelligence chief Sergei Naryshkin was invited by Mr. Putin to express his opinion whether Russia should recognize the separatist governments in the Donbass' Donetsk and Luhansk regions.
To do so would obviously be construed as a call to regional war with Russian troops dispatched to the territories prepared for a confrontation with Ukraine's military which would, as would any nation's military, defend Ukraine's geographic territorial imperative as a fully sovereign nation which another nation's defiance of national boundaries has placed at risk, including that posed to its citizens.
That the leaders of Donetsk and Luhansk had earlier evacuated hundreds of thousands of civilians from the territories to Russia, speaks of a pre-arranged agreement whose time had come.
In so doing, the invasion that the West warned was imminent and that Ukraine's President Volodomyr Zelensky beseeched the West for modern weaponry with which to counter Russia's move had anticipated. Naryshkin's first response was a hesitant feeling that Russia should allow Ukraine "one last chance to seek peace", an opinion that failed to impress Mr. Putin who responded, with a rictus smile:
"Do you want to recognize their sovereignty or do you want to launch talks?" The startled, sputtering intelligence chief was harshly prompted to "Speak up!". The immediate response was that the spy chief dropped his prevaricating stance, claiming his backing of the annexation of the separatist region, after all. "We're not talking about it, we're not debating it", a sneering Putin responded, shaking his head.
That little episode cautioned all others present that if they were at all invested in avoiding a slap-down by their president, they might be well advised to carefully weigh both their words and any expression of doubt over the president's feigned opinion-seeking over a matter he had long since debated within himself and arrived at an irreversible conclusion that they would prefer to avoid.
A woman in St. Petersburg, Russia, watching President Vladimir Putin address the nation on Monday.Credit...Anatoly Maltsev/EPA, via Shutterstock
Western intelligence has accused spy Chief Naryshkin of mounting massive cyberattacks on Ukraine, and he was in the presence of another two dozen senior officials all of whom were expected to present reports during the meeting, ostensibly to update the president on their findings and conclusions. A sham that stretched on for an hour and a half, all of which was broadcast on all major Russian TV channels.
Each of the attendees, one after the other, took to a lectern in the delivery of their assessment. Several appeared to be struck with stage fright, seemingly confused over what was expected of them. Mr. Putin, their stage-master and drama coach, drummed his fingers, appearing morosely unimpressed throughout the meeting's presentations. One can only wonder what ordinary Russians who viewed these sternly implacable-faced men with fear, thought of, seeing them humbled by their master.
"I was really struck not just by the toxic atmosphere, but also the King Lear vibe as courtiers were expected to vie with each other in playing the lunacy of the day", opined Mark Galeotti, a Russia expert and associate fellow with the Council on Geostrategy who compared the scene to witnessing a Shakespearean drama.
A
column of Russian armored vehicles, military trucks and supply units
about 60 miles away from the border with Ukraine on Monday.Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times
Soldiers inspect the remains of a car that the
Russian-backed separatists claim was blown up outside their
headquarters in Donetsk.Photograph: Alexander Ermochenko/Reuters
"[NATO and European leaders shared a call with me to discuss] Russia’s buildup of military troops on the border of Ukraine
and our continued efforts to pursue deterrence and diplomacy."
"The bottom line is this: The United States and our allies and partners
will support the Ukrainian people."
"We will hold Russia accountable for
its actions. The West is united and resolved. We’re ready to impose
severe sanctions on Russia if it further invades Ukraine."
U.S. President Joe Biden
"While of limited impact, this recent spate of cyber attacks in Ukraine
are consistent with what a Russian effort could look like, and laying
the groundwork for more disruptive cyberattacks accompanying a potential
further invasion of Ukraine sovereign territory."
Deputy U.S. National Security adviser for cyber and emerging technology Anne Neuberger
"[Moscow-backed separatists were] placing its artillery
systems near residential buildings [in the hope Kyiv's forces would
return fire."
"A day earlier,the Russian-backed separatists were
responsible for] a big provocation [after the shelling of a
kindergarten in territory controlled by the Ukrainian government."
"We
are constantly faced with provocations, shelling, cyberattacks,
dangerous maneuvers of aviation, disabling of mobile communications."
Ukrainian Defense Minister Oleksii Reznikov
Several hundred thousand citizens in the breakaway republics have been issued Russian passports in recent years. Nikolai Trishin / TASS
"The President of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, will soon order
the military to go on the offensive, implement a plan to invade the
territory of the Donetsk and Luhansk people's republics."
"Their weapons are pointed at civilians today."
"Women, children and the elderly are to be evacuated first."
"[Evacuation into the neighboring Rostov region has been coordinated with] Russian leadership."
Denis Pushilin, leader of the self-proclaimed Donetsk People’s Republic
"All Kyiv has to do is sit down at the negotiation table with
representatives of the Donbas and agree on political, military, economic
and humanitarian measures to end the conflict."
Russian President Vladimir Putin
People inside a bus arranged to evacuate local residents from the separatist-controlled city of Donetsk. Photograph: Alexander Ermochenko/Reuters
"Unfortunately, we don’t have a cellar, but we
heard the first noises, the teachers quickly took all the children and
rushed them into the corridor where there are no windows, and got them
all to lie on the floor."
"Then
we felt the close-up hit, the building shook and we could hear smashed
glass. There was real hysteria, the children were all screaming."
Elena Yaryna, School head teacher, Vrubivka, Eastern Ukraine
Russia
is fully engaged in exploring all possible scenarios where it can cast
blame on Ukraine for provoking Russia into a conflict that Russia itself
purportedly has ostensibly no wish to pursue. But, should Kyiv continue
to tax Russia's patience and goodwill to force its neighbour into a war
situation, Russia will not flinch, but will enter battle to protect its
interests; namely its territory in Crimea, and the lives and future of
ethnic Russian Ukrainians in the Donbass region of Ukraine.
Ukraine
continues to push Russia into this impossible situation where it must
engage militarily for its own security and that of its people and its
territories. The Ukrainian military given orders to continue shelling
positions in Donetsk and Luhansk, endangering the lives of residents
there and pushing the leaders of those territories, now separate from
Ukraine, to defend themselves. Ukraine forces bombing an elementary
school. These scurrilous attacks on innocent people by Kyiv-ordered
military are quite simply intolerable.
Or they would be, if they
weren't set-ups, like the bombing of a vehicle supposedly belonging to
one of the separatist leaders, all leading to incredible
reasons why Moscow has been pushed to its limits to respond to
Ukrainian aggression. An aggression meant to drive out the leaders of
Luhanks and Donetsk, meant to drive Russia away from the Crimean
Peninsula so critical to Russia's interests. Fierce aggression on the
part of Ukraine has driven the leaders of the People's Republics of
Luhansk and Donetsk to consider the safety of civilians, two million
people who now must be evacuated.
That's the perspective of the
Russian propaganda published in Russia for the edification of Russians
who have no wish to engage in a war with their neighbour but whom their
government thinks of as being credulous enough to believe what it
claims. For they are either patriotic, loyal to the Kremlin and Vladimir
Putin, or they are traitors to the Russian Federation. Moscow claims
the move to evacuate Russian Ukrainians to feed a sense of panic meant
to lead to 'defensive' moves against Ukrainian aggression, was not
discussed beforehand with their leadership.
A big surprise, although Moscow has offered to each of the evacuees, a bonus gift of 10,000 rubles (equivalent to US$130),
food, lodging and medical care. Uprooting two million people to 'prove'
that the situation is so dangerously dire as a result of Ukrainian
aggression that such a desperate action is needed and justifiable. There
was a response from the U.S., the administration characterizing the
evacuation as a "cynical" move by Moscow.
"Announcements like these are further attempts to obscure through
lies and disinformation that Russia is the aggressor in this conflict", clarified a
State Department spokesperson. "It is also cynical and cruel to use human
beings as pawns to distract the world from the fact that Russia is
building up its forces in preparation for an attack."
But
there it is; civilians packed onto buses in eastern Ukraine, headed for
Russia. Russia took measures years ago to issue Russian passports to
ethnic Russian Ukrainians in the Donbass. Manipulating people on such a
large-scale basis to further Mr. Putin's plan of manoeuvring Ukraine
into a response that would ignite the conflict he is so determined to
launch is, in very fact, not only cynical but cruel. A testament to his
incorrigible aspirations to absorb Ukraine once again into the Russian
Federation.
"There are no orders to liberate our territories by force",
responded Oleksiy Danilov, Ukraine's top security authority. Families
were ordered to assemble to board buses at an evacuation point in
Donetsk where the intention is to have 700,000 people transported to
Russia. Some refuse to go; male civilians are urged to join the
separatists to fight for their country, and the country they're urged to
fight for is not Ukraine. "This is my motherland and the land is ours, I will stay and put out the fires", said 62-year-old Konstantin Lysanov.
Intense
artillery bombardment has unsettled residents. Ukraine states that the
separatist rebel militias initiated the violence, and Ukraine is accused
by the militia leaders of Donetsk and Luhansk of launching the original
volleys. As far as the West is concerned, the shelling which
intensified in recent days would be just another attempt by Vladimir
Putin's government for a pretext to justify an attack on Ukraine.
Of
the former 14 republics under Russian control during the days of the
USSR, Ukraine's decision to leave Russia for independence was Russia's
most painful loss, one that Mr. Putin refers to as the greatest
geopolitical catastrophe of the last century when the Soviet Union
dissolved. He has set his legacy aspiration on restoring Russia's global
power standing through defiance of the West. As a result, fear of a
wider war in Europe has affected markets and produced a diplomatic
crisis.
"We see additional forces going to the border including leading edge forces",
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken informed the Munich Security
Conference, noting that American intelligence assesses that Russia now
has about 50 percent of its total forces assembled to confront Ukraine
on all fronts across its vast territory bordering Russia and Belarus and
the separatist territories. "This is the most significant military mobilization in Europe since the Second World War", U.S. ambassador Michael Carpenter noted.
"There's what Russia says. And then there's what Russia does. And we haven't seen any pullback of its forces."
"We continue to see critical units moving toward the border, not away from the border."
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken
Russian army tanks move back to their permanent base after drills in
Russia [Russian Defence Ministry Press Service via AP Photo]
Wednesday was designated by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy a patriotic holiday. this, in puckish response to reports that Russia could invade on that very day. "No one can love our home as we can. And only we, together, can protect our home", he said to his citizens. And so, Ukrainians responded by singing the national anthem, and waving Ukrainian flags in defiance of what may turn out to be a conflagration from a volatile situation, tensely expectant.
Wednesday came and Wednesday went, the Russia sneered in contempt. Even as the United States and NATO continue to warn that troops were still arriving to join those that had been stationed at the border with Ukraine for months on end. While Russian President Vladimir Putin insists that he/Russia have no desire for war he has also been intransigent in diplomatic talks over his security concerns for Russia; to placate those concerns NATO would have to submit to Russia's terms.
The cyberattack that hit the Ukrainian defence ministry was a serious one. Moscow denied involvement, Ukraine is convinced it is the source, and with good reason. Punishment for Ukraine's ambition to seek membership in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization; for refusing to accede to Russia's expectation that it must return to the Soviet fold, for insisting it has every right to remain sovereign, to make its own decisions over its future and that of its people.
The standoff continues with Russia's defence ministry stating that its forces were pulling back following exercises in southern and western military districts adjacent Ukraine. Its video showed, the ministry emphasized, tanks, infantry fighting vehicles and self-propelled artillery units exiting the Crimean peninsula. Although Moscow seized Crimea in 2014, under international law it remains an integral part of Ukraine within Ukraine's vast geography.
The risk of Russian aggression against Ukraine would remain for the entirety of February; Russia could still attack "with essentially no, or little-to-no, warning", stated a senior Western intelligence official. Moving troops and tanks back and forth was not proof of a pullout, observed NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg. "What we see is that they have increased the number of troops and more troops are on their way. So, so far, no de-escalation", he stated.
There is, in fact, satellite imagery in NATO's possession proving the failure by Russia to pull back its troops. Oleksii Reznikov, Ukraine's Defence Minister, possesses intelligence that similarly shows no sign of a Russian pull-back The combined strength of Russian military and pro-Russian separatist forces near Ukraine's borders stood at roughly 140,000, he acknowledged.
Is this a case of Vladimir Putin simply enjoying the opportunity to put Europe on edge? His devilish spirit of confrontation and innocence of intent as a provocateur-par-excellence on full display? It is a power play and he excels at it. Russia has invested steeply in recent years in upgrading wholesale its military capabilities, in the possession of advanced technological military machines equal of any in the arsenals of the West.
But no, this is deadly serious. If the West really, truly wants de-escalation it must take seriously Moscow's concerns over its fragility in the face of near-abroad neighbours' adversarial positions, allying themselves with an ideological collective diametrically opposed to Russia's own. Russia needs distancing, and NATO stubbornly resists creating the necessary corridor between East and West that Russia requires for security comfort.
Ukraine has increased its border guard numbers on its frontier with Belarus allied with Russia, where about 9,000 Russian troops are involved in military exercises. Hackers continue to bombard Ukraine's defence ministry through vulnerabilities which has led the ministry to reroute traffic to servers in the United States temporarily.
NATO military commanders are preparing plans for new combat units to be deployed in Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary and Slovakia designed to fill a gap until additional troops can be deployed to the front line if needed. Where they are already in place in Poland and the Baltic states. The U.K. is prepared to double its force size in Estonia and dispatch tanks and armoured fighting vehicles to the Baltic republic bordering Russia; part of NATO deployment.
The phone call had been delayed since Monday owing to Johnson’s need to answer questions on the Sue Gray report.Photograph: Tayfun Salcı/Zuma/Rex/Shutterstock
"The prime minister expressed his deep concern about Russia's current hostile activity on the Ukrainian border,"
"He emphasized the need to find a way forward which respects both
Ukraine's territorial integrity and right to self-defense. The prime
minister stressed that any further Russian incursion into Ukrainian
territory would be a tragic miscalculation."
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson's Office
"It's already clear now ... that fundamental Russian concerns were ignored."
"Let's imagine Ukraine is a NATO member and starts these military operations. Are we supposed to go to war with the NATO bloc?"
"Has anyone given that any thought? Apparently not."
Russian President Vladimir Putin
Russian
President Vladimir Putin attends a session of the board of trustees of
the Russian Geographical Society via a video conference call in Moscow (credit: VIA REUTERS)
Indeed,
much attention has been given to that question. It is actually so
fundamental to the reason that Ukraine would like to be a member of
NATO, like some of its neighbours. For the assurance that Moscow would
think deeply about what it is considering in returning Russia to its
former glory days of absorbing its near-abroad neighbours once again
into the warm embrace of its octopus grasp as satellites revolving
around Soviet Russia.
And
it is precisely that aspiration that so concerns Russia's neighbours
that they grasp at the opportunity of having the assurance that a group
will be looking out for their interests of sovereignty and security. So
Mr. Putin in posing that hypothetical question is merely being
disingenuous. His actions belie innocence of that knowledge and the
question answers itself poignantly in the dread memories haunting the
former captive members of the USSR.
On
Tuesday Mr. Putin accused the West of ignoring Russia's security
concerns, deliberately creating a war scenario to suit their purposes
with the added insult of humiliating Russia. On Wednesday, Mr. Putin
shared a conversation with Britain's Prime Minister, but before that
conversation took place, an odd occurrence had Britain slightly on edge
as they scrambled fighters to 'escort' Russian bombers approaching
British airspace. Intimidation? heaven forfend such a thought...!
A Russian TU-95 bomber photo credit: REUTERS)
"Quick Reaction Alert Typhoon fighters based at RAF Lossiemouth
supported by a Voyager from RAF Brize Norton were scrambled today
against unidentified aircraft approaching the UK area of interest."
"Subsequently, we intercepted and escorted four Russian Bear aircraft,"
Royal Air Force spokesman
Mr.
Putin shared a news conference with the prime minister of Hungary,
visiting, as one of several NATO leaders making an effort to intercede
with him, during the crisis where it is abundantly apparent that Russia
has planned another invasion of Ukraine. Mr. Putin, defiant against NATO
demands that he have Russian troops and armaments removed from the
border with Ukraine, has no intention of backing away from his own
security demands.
NATO
warns Russia that it will not tolerate an invasion of a sovereign
nation without exacting painful sanctions against Russia, while Russia
insists that it has the right and the will power to persuade the Western
alliance to withdraw its presence from Russia's near-abroad -- where
NATO member-states have sent troops to other invasion-vulnerable former
satellites of the USSR -- and never consider allowing Ukraine to join
the alliance.
Russia,
which in 2014 surprised the international community by invading Ukraine
-- and supporting ethnic Russian Ukrainian separatist rebels in the
Donbas region of eastern Ukraine in their violent separation aspirations
in Donetsk and Luhansk, then swooped in on the Crimean peninsula to
claim it as Russian territory -- expresses concern that as a member of
NATO Ukraine might take it upon itself to reclaim Crimea, is downright
risible.
With
over 100,000 troops massed on the border with Ukraine, setting itself
up for an invasion, Russia denies it has any such intentions; the
troops, the arms, and the field hospitals are merely a practise
performance, not a rehearsal. However, it now says, should its security
demands not be met it could decide to take military action of an
unspecified nature. Denials and verification.
"If
President Putin really does not intend war or regime change, the
Secretary [U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken] told Foreign Minister
Lavrov then this is the time to pull back troops and heavy weaponry and
engage in a serious discussion ... that can enhance collective European
security."
U.S. State Department official
President
Putin has been silent since mid-December until the present, with an
atmosphere of ambiguity on his decision-making, inspiring diplomats from
Russia and the West to engage in repeated rounds of talks in the hope
of defusing the crisis. His remarks this week paint a picture of
Russia's need to defend itself from a hostile U.S. concerned not with
Ukraine's security, but its intention to contain Russia.
And
just as Russia refuses to be dictated to by the United States, the
Biden administration has now announced its decision to deploy 2,000
troops from Fort Bragg, members of the 82nd Airborne Division infantry
brigade to go to Poland. The deployment, said Poland's Defense Minister
is "a strong signal of solidarity in response to the situation in Ukraine".
Of
the total number, several hundred with the 18th Airborne Corps are set
to arrive in Germany representing what the Pentagon spoke of as a "joint task force-capable headquarters". And Mr. Putin is free to make of that what he will.
A Ukrainian serviceman on the frontline in Donetsk.Photograph: Anatolii Stepanov/AFP/Getty Images
Ukraine
President Volodymyr Zelensky said the US and NATO are creating panic in
his country over a potential Russian invasion Future Publishing via Getty Images
"I'm the president of Ukraine, I'm based here and I think I know the details deeper than any other president."
"Do we have tanks on the streets? They go around saying 'War starts tomorrow'."
"It creates panic. Panic in the financial sector. It costs Ukraine a lot."
Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky
"Compared to the document we received from NATO, the U.S. response could almost be called a paragon of diplomatic politesse."
"If
it depends on Russia, there will be no war. We don't want wars. But we
also won't allow our interests to be rudely trampled, to be ignored."
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov
"[Russia has massed enough forces to launch a full-scale invasion -- of Ukraine -- with] little warning."
"[The Russian buildup is] larger in scale and scope than anything we've seen in recent memory."
U.S. General Mark Milley, chairman, U.S. joint chiefs of staff
President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia said in December that his demands must be addressed “right away, right now.”Credit...Pool photo by Aleksey Nikolskyi
Ukraine's
president feels as though he and his country are being pushed around.
Not only by his country's former nemesis and its current incarnation,
but also by the very countries that have stepped into the breach of
threatening standoff, and in their eagerness to promote their version of
what may be expected to occur, and when, creating an indelible internal
aura of stress and panic. Whereas President Zelensky would prefer
projecting an air of confidence over a situation that would have grave
consequences for the sovereign right of his country, putting up a brave
facade while appealing to the West to exert pressure on Moscow, he hears
stark predictions of impending disaster.
Predictions
that seem to him premature, that all diplomatic overtures have not been
fully employed to de-escalate; rather than exacerbate tensions, those
who claim to be committed to Ukraine's salvation as a securely
independent member of the international community of nations are being
unnecessarily provocative and heating up their exchanges in volumes of
threats and repercussions.
The
White House, he publicly complained was "amplifying" the risk Ukraine
is facing, an alarmist attitude too extreme to reflect the current
situation which, he emphases, represents a "mistake in my opinion",
a surprising rebuke to the rash statements of approaching doom
expressed by the White House. The comments emerged following a telephone
call with President Biden, a call that a Ukrainian official described
as one that "did not go well".
"On
the one hand, [Zelensky] wants assistance. But on the other, he has to
assure his people he has the situation under control. That's a tricky
balance", observed a White House official. The sense
of swiftly impending collision between NATO, the United States, Ukraine
and Russia has been heightened by a new revelation that the military
buildup of Russian troops and equipment on the border with Ukraine has
expanded to the inclusion of blood supplies required for anticipated
casualties in the event of an imminent conflict.
In
communications with France's President Macron, Mr. Putin spoke of the
West having "ignored" security concerns expressed by Russia over its
perception of NATO expansion into Russia's near-abroad, a geography that
Vladimir Putin regards as Russia's diplomatic-political domain into
which a Western presence has become a destabilizing feature and a threat
to Russia's relationships with its near neighbours. According to a
French official, Mr. Putin indicated "very clearly that he did not want confrontation".
And
nor would Beijing -- Moscow's great good friend and collegial partner
in defending joint interests against Western interference -- appreciate
violent confrontation. At least not right now. It would be most
inconvenient, most unsuitable in view of their warm relations, for
Russia to embark on an incendiary war situation that would surely spread
and absorb the world's attention at the very time that China is hosting
the Winter Olympics.
A
White House official notes that Russia'a protestations of having no
intention of invading its neighbour is welcome, but it would be far more
convincing for it to withdraw its troops from Ukraine's border. Mr.
Putin has been accused by the U.S. ambassador in Moscow of "putting a gun on the table and saying 'I come in peace'."
Russia
has been given assurances from the U.S. that such a withdrawal would
entitle it in exchange to have a delegation of Russian inspectors visit
missile sites entrenched by the U.S. in Poland and Romania to reduce its
fears that the missiles are aimed at Russia, and not as claimed, in the
direction of Iran. In the relentless standoff, the U.S. now considers
an action independent of NATO to itself and the U.K. in a "coalition of
the willing" to include other allies, moving troops closer to Russia to
deter Putin's plans.
A
Ukrainian service member kneels next to a howitzer during artillery and
anti-aircraft drills near the border with Russian-annexed Crimea in the
Kherson region of Ukraine.via REUTERS
This represents a general opinion site for its author. It also offers a space for the author to record her experiences and perceptions,both personal and public. This is rendered obvious by the content contained in the blog, but the space is here inviting me to write. And so I do.